Jump to content
Gentleman's Military Interest Club

peter monahan

Moderator
  • Content count

    4,070
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by peter monahan


  1. Nero

    30 years ago when I was actively involved in buying medals and badges, the wisdom on the street was that 30- 50% of the WWII German stuff on the market was repro/fake.  I can't imagine that the % has gone down!  No easy answer except to talk to people you trust to be honest and experienced in the field and resist - its very hard! - the urge to buy quickly.

    I have no idea whether this is a good one, but there are lots of experts and lots of examples out there.  Here are two sites which m,ay shed a little light on the question.  Good luck with your collecting!

    Peter

    http://quanonline.com/military/military_reference/german/german_replicas.html


  2. One of the vendors in a large local antique market has an entire case full of 'unique', 'very rare' and 'extremely rare' items.  Two or three of the 30 actually are.  It makes me wonder where all the 'ordinary' and 'common' stuff has got to. :(  Although in this case the vendor has offered some 'evidence' for his/her claim.  Is the source reliable?  Are there other similar sources?

     


  3. Below are the ribbons for the campaign medals   identified:General Service Medal, 1947, Paschimi Star, 1971, Samar Seva, 1965, Raksha Medal, 1965, 1971-72, Sainya Seva Medal.  Judging by this area, the officer was a late WWII or just post-war enlistment – GSM 1947 – and served until at least 1971.  Quite a career and clearly ‘at the sharp end’ a good bit, as one would expect from a Gunner.  Shabash, huzzor!

     

    India_General_Service_Medal_1947.svg.png

    IND_Paschimi_Star_Ribbon.svg.png

    IND_Samar_Seva_Star_Ribbon.svg.png

    IND_Raksha_Medal_Ribbon.svg.png

    IND_Sainya_Seva_Medal_Ribbon.svg.png


  4. The awarding of rosettes began with napoleon, according to this source and was first done in the US in 1877.  I would have pegged it somewhat later in the UK, as until the late 19th century, full size medals were the norm and decorations worn on civilian dress failry rare, I think.  [https://www.hodgesbadge.com/history-of-rosettes/a/7/]

    I don't know anything about the Air medal and multiples, but when Canadian service personnel earned the UN medal for service in Cyprus in the '60-'90s, many were there 4-6-8 times, especially if they were support or signals and we eventually authorized a metal numeral to wear on the ribbon because that many rosettes just looked silly!


  5. OTOH, even 'military' tailors - the chaps who thrive outside any large base -are not actually constrained by the regulations which apply to memebrs of the various armed forces and there are some wild and wonderful things out there on the chests [or walls] of current and former officers. 

    And depending on the rank of the wearer, few people qualified or willing to make a complaint, official or otherwise.  The classic example was Lord Montgomery of El Alamein.  When he was serving he typically wore an RTR beret with two badges on it, completely against all regulations and radition.  But who would say him nay?  No one, apparently, as it became his 'trademark'.

    My guess would be that Chase lost or never had the appropriate device for his DFC ribbon and requested a tailor to 'fix that', this being the solution.  

    My two cents worth!


  6. Most of 'Dada' Amin's medals were self awarded in the latter stages of his leadership.  He joined the KAR post WWII, as a cook, and was with them in Somalia - battling Shufta cattle raiders apparently - but would not, I think, have received any real medals for that.  Rose to the rank of Effendi [Warrant Officer] in the British KAR and eventually deputy commander of the post independence Ugandan Army.

    Wikipedia says this of his awards:

    After the United Kingdom broke off all diplomatic relations with his regime in 1977, Amin declared he had defeated the British, and conferred on himself the decoration of CBE (Conqueror of the British Empire). His full self-bestowed title ultimately became: "His Excellency, President for Life, Field Marshal Al Hadji Doctor Idi Amin Dada, VC, DSOMC, Lord of All the Beasts of the Earth and Fishes of the Seas and Conqueror of the British Empire in Africa in General and Uganda in Particular", in addition to his officially-stated claim of being the uncrowned King of Scotland.  He never received the Distinguished Service Order (DSO) or the Military Cross (MC). He conferred a doctorate of law on himself from Makerere University as well as the Victorious Cross (VC), a medal made to emulate the British Victoria Cross.

    Getty Images will happily sell you a shot of him wearing all his awards. ;)


  7. Davies

    Good on ya, as the Aussies say! 

    'BigJarof Wasps posted what look like newspaper photos, so I'd assume he has some clues.  Try sending him a message - click on his name and you can send a private message.  Also try googling the gent on Facebook and social media, though as an ex-NI type that is probably going to be less helpful.  Good luck!

    Peter


  8. Lone Wolf

    I'm guessing from your comments, and your location, if I've puzzled it out correctly, that you may be close to some sources for IA medals as well.  Thanks for your generous offer, and please do stick around to offer your views on similar posts!

    Peter


  9. Gard

     #69

    Can any one tell me the 3 different  in 

    1. Yemen Arab Republic:
      Wound Badge.
    2. People's Democratic Republic of Yemen:
      Order of War Wounded.
    3. Republic of Yemen:
      Wound Badge.
    4. Thanks
    5. Rod

    t's a little complicated, but basically, I think, three awards issued by either two or three different states: one by 'North Yemen', one by 'South Yemen' and one by the united state just known as 'Yemen'.  I'll leave you to sort out which is which.

    Yemen Arab Republic also known as North Yemen or Yemen (Sana'a), was a country from 1962 to 1990 in the northwestern part of what is now Yemen.

    The People's Democratic Republic of Yemen , also referred to as South YemenDemocratic Yemen,  or the South Arabian Federation, was a socialist state in the southern and eastern provinces of the present-day Republic of Yemen.

    It was united with the Yemen Arab Republic (commonly known as "North Yemen") on 22 May 1990 to form Yemen

    Peter Monahan

     

    oamotme

    • Full Member
    • oamotme
    • Silver Membership
    • 844 posts
    • Location:Riyadh, Saudi Arabia

    Gard,

    I attach images of the two variations of the YAR wound badge which I purchased in Sana'a in the 1990's.

    Peter,

    As Moderator can I ask that you transfer to a new topic the last three posts as 'Yemeni Wound Awards'?

    Many thanks,

    Owain

     

    YAR Wound Badges Master Measurement.jpg

    YAR Wound Badges Master A Large.jpg

    YAR Wound Badges Master B Smalll.jpg


  10. Gard

    • Basic Member
    • Basic Membership
    • 6 posts
    • Location:Australia

    Can any one tell me the 3 different  in 

    1. Yemen Arab Republic:
      Wound Badge.
    2. People's Democratic Republic of Yemen:
      Order of War Wounded.
    3. Republic of Yemen:
      Wound Badge.
    4. Thanks
    5. Rod

     

    It's a little complicated, but basically, I think, three awards issued by either two or three different states: one by 'North Yemen', one by 'South Yemen' and one by the united state just known as 'Yemen'.  I'll leave you to sort out which is which.

    Yemen Arab Republic also known as North Yemen or Yemen (Sana'a), was a country from 1962 to 1990 in the northwestern part of what is now Yemen.

    The People's Democratic Republic of Yemen , also referred to as South YemenDemocratic Yemen,  or the South Arabian Federation, was a socialist state in the southern and eastern provinces of the present-day Republic of Yemen.

    It was united with the Yemen Arab Republic (commonly known as "North Yemen") on 22 May 1990 to form Yemen

    oamotme

    • Full Member
    • oamotme
    • Silver Membership
    • 844 posts
    • Location:Riyadh, Saudi Arabia

    Gard,

    I attach images of the two variations of the YAR wound badge which I purchased in Sana'a in the 1990's.

    Owain

     

    YAR Wound Badges Master Measurement.jpg

    YAR Wound Badges Master A Large.jpg

    YAR Wound Badges Master B Smalll.jpg

×