Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Post yourImperial russian orders and badges


    GeorgeCL

    Recommended Posts

    That's about it. Also the medals of St. George (the four-classed version, post 1878) were numbered.

    It's nice too see this new forum, I too hope it grows. The imperial Russian award system is most interesting, and in my opinion these orders - especially those made pre-1914 - are amongst the most beautiful around. Too bad they command such high prizes that I can't afford buying them. :( Well.. maybe some day.. until then I'll have to settle for looking them in pictures.

    Nice examples, gentlemen. :beer:

    Pete

    * * * * *

    PeteA

    Is it your contention that all St. George Crosses had to be numbered to be legitimate? Are you sure?

    Consider that it was common for private masters to make St. George Crosses on special order that were not numbered. These were worn as if they had come from government stock, assuming the wearer was entitled to the award, of course. Also, I think the base metal crosses were not well received and some soldiers, especially officers, bought precious metal versions with their own funds, if they had any.

    Was it not also the case that very late-war Turkish Front "Soldiers Committee" St. George Crosses were not numbered?

    Thus, might not there be examples that were legitimate but not numbered?

    I think it is likely that not all authentic awarded St. George Crosses were numbered. However, I freely admit my ignorance here, and I do not claim to be an expert of any kind, merely a curious collector.

    Chuck

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Replies 57
    • Created
    • Last Reply

    Top Posters In This Topic

    * * * * *

    PeteA

    Is it your contention that all St. George Crosses had to be numbered to be legitimate? Are you sure?

    Consider that it was common for private masters to make St. George Crosses on special order that were not numbered. These were worn as if they had come from government stock, assuming the wearer was entitled to the award, of course. Also, I think the base metal crosses were not well received and some soldiers, especially officers, bought precious metal versions with their own funds, if they had any.

    Was it not also the case that very late-war Turkish Front "Soldiers Committee" St. George Crosses were not numbered?

    Thus, might not there be examples that were legitimate but not numbered?

    I think it is likely that not all authentic awarded St. George Crosses were numbered. However, I freely admit my ignorance here, and I do not claim to be an expert of any kind, merely a curious collector.

    Chuck

    Hi Chuck,

    neither can I claim to be any kind of an expert, nor hardly even a proper collector.. and keeping in mind that I have never owned a St. George cross, here goes nothing..

    First of all, I also think that not all the official St. George crosses were numbered. Anything is possible, especially after 1917. But for me the number (assuming that it matches the award rolls) is one proof of originality.

    The crosses and medals of St. George were awarded to the recipients by the Russian government. Of course, the recipient could purchase a privately made piece too.

    For example, the recipient in the need of money could sell his gold cross and purchase a duplicate one, made out of bronze. As in the same way a recipient who was decorated with a bronze cross (war-time material reduction, after October 1916) could purchase a golden one, if he had the money. But since this was an award for the other ranks, I'd say that the first option was more common.

    But the thing being, like you said, that whether you obtained a totally new cross, or had your old one duplicated, you needed to have the provenance that you were entitled for the cross. And if you had the provenance, as far as I know, you also had the number. And why would the jeweller not engrave/stamp that number on these privately made crosses too?

    On your comment about officers purchasing St. George crosses, I know that those "Soldiers Committees" awarded these crosses to some officers, is this what you mean? Or a case where an EM/NCO was promoted to officer, but naturally kept wearing his St George(s) after that?

    By the way, here is a good, but a bit unstable site about St. George crosses, maybe more information can be found there: http://nubirus.chat.ru/HomepageEnglish.htm

    Regards,

    Pete

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Good Morning Pete

    First, thank you for the web site reference. I have several in my "Favorites" folder but I didn't have that one.

    I have one numbered silver St. George Cross with absolutely no provenance. It came from another collector. I have a gold unnumbered example with a good provenance as told by the family from whom I bought it. Of course, anyone can make up a story, but I tend to believe the family histories when I hear them in the first person.

    I also have a group that includes an un-numbered gold example from a titled Georgian family who stated that the recipient definitely did purchase that example. Yet, I have a soldier's committee example with ribbon and leaves, awarded to a young officer, that is numbered.

    I don't quite know what to make of all this. My limited experience is that there were more unnumbered examples than I might previously have thought. I know that owing an example does not imply knowledge of any sort, and I claim none. I have stopped asking questions of the "Why would they ... " nature, because I simply have too many of them.

    Thank you for your thought-provoking response.

    Chuck

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Guest Rick Research

    Russian (Soviet) serial numbers are a bit of a "fixation" with me, for dating undocumented awards--

    a specific thread on the George Crosses and Medals with any know approximate numbers range that would distinguish, say, Russo-Japanese numbers from WW1 would be most welcome! :beer:

    There was no Soviet subforum here 6 months ago either. We built it, and they came, to paraphrase "The Field of Dreams." :rolleyes:

    To the growth and expansion of the Imperial Russian/Civil War subforum! :cheers:

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 3 weeks later...

    This beautifull breaststar of the one-class Alexander Newsky-Order walked through my collection in 2005 . I mean i bought it for little money. Only weeks ago some other collector made an offer i could not resist and the Newsky was gone. I have been told the star is of european, probably french manufacture and dates arround 1850/60. No markers mark, no hallmarks made of silver and gold

    haynau

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 2 weeks later...

    I would like to raise a question relative to the bronze gilt Imperial Russian oirder insignia that have been on the market since the early 1990's.

    1. A bit of background: I have a large number of books on Faberge, many of which have chapters devoted to the hallmarks that that company used to mark their products. Even though I know that their marks were struck into the surface of the items, I have noticed that a number of the reference pictures - due to a quirk of the raking light used to make the detail of each hallmark stand out - actually make the mark look like it's somehow raised above the surface of the object.

    2. Now to specifics: the majority of St. Anne and St. Stanislaus crosses made of bronze gilt that I've seen are marked Eduard and the name (along, sometimes, with other marks such as single letters) is on a small rectangle raised above the surface of the cross.

    3. Here's my proposition: that dies to make copies of imperial russian orders were cut by someone, post-1918, who, working from photos, mistook the nature of the Eduard hallmark - perhaps in a reference photo - and cut his die with the hallmark raised above rather than sunk into the surface of the metal.

    I spent a couple of weeks in Russia last summer and was interested to note that many "high-end" gift shops and some museums, too, were busily flogging copies of virtually every degree of every Imperial Russian order. I did not examine any of them close-up because they all seemed to be made with acryillic enamel and were downright clunky in appearance...

    So , what I'm wondering is this: could there have been an earlier generation of Imperial copies made of bronze gilt and with hot enamel that were designed to be sold in gift shops and that those souvenir awards are what we were buying in the early nineties because we assumed that they were late WW I production? (After all, most everyone knows how the WW I combattant nations pulled the plug on the non-essential use of gold and silver during that war - so order insignia made of bronze gilt seemed to make sense...)

    Jim

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Russian (Soviet) serial numbers are a bit of a "fixation" with me, for dating undocumented awards--

    a specific thread on the George Crosses and Medals with any know approximate numbers range that would distinguish, say, Russo-Japanese numbers from WW1 would be most welcome! :beer:

    That would indeed be a terrific idea. I for one am desperately looking for info on the serial number range of the St George medals and crosses the Belgian Auto-canon regiment received during world war 1.

    I already know they received 104 awards in total, crosses and medals mixed. Apparantly the medals are not numbered, I have seen 1 in a private collection and have reliable info from the Belgian Army Museum.

    I have no info on the crosses though.

    Let's go for it :jumping:

    Jan

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Some very remarkable pieces, gentlemen. Thank you for sharing them.

    * * * * *

    Hello Bob

    I've got a few things due to arrive Tuesday that I think you'll like. I'm pretty sure that one of them is uncatalogued and completely unknown in the west. Stay tuned and I'll post most of them.

    Meantime everyone, have a safe and happy 2006 and thank you for your company here.

    Chuck

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 4 weeks later...

    OK, where's the new goodies? More, more, more please! ;>)

    * * * * *

    OK, stop panting. I've got more to share but I have been way busy lately. The first group I'm going to share will be Soviet, but you'll like it anyway. Maybe on Saturday, if I can clear the time.

    BTW, my buddy is still negotiating on the attributed gold badge of the first commander of the Caucasus Air Fleet. I plan to go over in the spring and I hope to bring it home with me. With gold at over $560, prices are really getting ridiculous.

    Chuck

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 1 month later...

    French Awards group with Russian St George cross .

    Receipient -

    Marechal des logis Bellet Henri Felix from 6 regiment de Hussards

    Receive Russian cross and Croix de Guerre in 1915 ,

    Order of Legion d'Honneur (chevalier) in 1923 - lieutenant 156 Inf. Reg .

    Another British St. George Awards 1915 -

    http://gmic.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=6485

    http://gmic.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=6439

    Edited by Igor Ostapenko
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.