Jump to content
Gentleman's Military Interest Club

Recommended Posts

Gentlemen;

Theses are all wonderful bars.  :love::love:  Thank you for starting this thread Chris.

I have a couple of entries, but right now I can only add the link to my favorite.  I will confess in advance, it is a bit of a cheat to the category. ;)  Yes, he was a NCO during the fighting, but later became a (Prison) Officer and earned some additional awards.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is very unusual.... I would have thought that if he recieved the Olympic medla, he would have been sure to already have a Hindenburg?

Nice Bar!

I have a problem with this bar too, the Ehrenkreuz for Frontkämpfer should be on the bar, and it wasn´t allowed to fix such an aluminium medal on black, white and red ribbon on a bar at this time. Please show a photo from the back.

Regards
Andreas

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is very unusual.... I would have thought that if he recieved the Olympic medla, he would have been sure to already have a Hindenburg?

Nice Bar!

The Hindenburg was not given out to my understanding. A person had to apply for it during 34/35. If this guy did not apply for it he would not have it on his bar. He was most likely done with war and then was somehow pulled back in as a civilian in uniform to get the Olympic medal and 25 year LS. I have a two war NC bar that has the Olympic and a similar LS award with no Hindenburg. It was blessed by Rick as original.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I suppose it is technically possible, but veeeery unusual... the Treuedienst Ehrenzeichen was introduced in 1938... So he was still kicking around without having applied for the Hindie (even more unusual as he was an official) and he also still has the unofficial Red White and black ribonned medal on it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The flip side of the coin.... if someone were to fake a bar this well... would be make such a howling error and leave off the Hindie for an unofficial medal? I think that may just be even more unlikey than a Vet not having it put on?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Paul,

On some bars it is not possible. The others you can tell by the awards. Certain awards were given to specific ranks. The higher ranks would get the wreathed or crowned version (Saxony). Long service medals are also a good tell. Some senior officers have bars that get smaller as awards move to the neck.  They look like an enlisted/NCO bar but the officer LS is still there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How can someone distinguish an NCO bar from an officer's bar?

There are certain grades of awards that were awarded to NCOs.  For instance, Bavarian privates received the 3rd Class MVK while the higher grades went to the higher enlisted ranks.  Officers would get, at least, the enameled 4th Class Order.  Also, the presence of an enlisted long service award is another indication.

On the Saxony/Reuss group above, there are both the Reuss merit medal, an enlisted award, and the Reuss House Order, 3rd Class, an officer's award.  There is also a 15 Year Long Service Cross which was awarded only to enlisted men.  This indicates several years of pre-war service.  This guy probably started the war as an NCO but received a commission sometime later.

A purely officer's bar will often have house orders.  The only long service awards on an officer's bars will be those designated for officers such as the Prussian 25 year cross for line officers or the 20 year cross for reserve officers.  In the case of an officer who had shorter service and had not been awarded a house order, there is no way to tell.  Prussian officers often received only the Iron Cross which was available to all ranks.

 

Edited by Beau Newman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is one of my favorites....sorry about the picture...I am using an iPad.

image.jpg

and another...I have gone through the REM awards to see what I could find......I suspect a bandmember or a steward aboard the Kaisers' yaucht or some such person...

image.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gentlemen,

 

Some really beautiful bars shown here. Thank you all for sharing. Here is my candidate. The awards to Feldwebel Hermann Stude of the 4th Guards Grenadier Regt. -

0.1050201 copy.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow Chris!.... that's a stunning German unifications wars medal bar.... with the Russian St. George Cross really highly desirable...

Ciao,

 

Claudio

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Beau,

Thank you for the detailed explanation.  So Prussian bars could go either way, in most cases.

You all have some mind blowing medal bars.  

This bar(Below) is simply amazing.  Feldwebel Hermann Stude saw a lot of history: Second Schleswig War and BOTH wars of unification.  WOW.  He has the full house going on there.  I bet he had a lot of great "war stories."

 

Gentlemen,

 

Some really beautiful bars shown here. Thank you all for sharing. Here is my candidate. The awards to Feldwebel Hermann Stude of the 4th Guards Grenadier Regt. -

0.1050201 copy.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is one of my favorites....sorry about the picture...I am using an iPad.

image.jpg

and another...I have gone through the REM awards to see what I could find......I suspect a bandmember or a steward aboard the Kaisers' yaucht or some such person...

image.jpg

Hi Ulsterman,

I like your bar with the Rote Adler - Medaille

When you look through the Rangliste der kaiserlich deutschen Marine from 1914, you will find

a couple of possible recipients, not all aboard Kaisers Yacht. For eyample such as Oberbootsleute Arpe from

I. Matrosendivision and Bootsleute Eckhoff from I. Matrosendivision both with AEZ, DA1, RAM and Centenarmedaille.

Regards
Andreas

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One more. The group of Oberfeuerwerker Kurt Porske.

In the navy from 1902, serving on many ships (S.M.S. HERTHA, S.M.S. LORELEY, S.M.S. MÜNCHEN, S.M.S. MAGDEBURG, S.M.S. KAISER, S.M.S. PRINZREGENT LUITPOLD, S.M.S. KOENIG). He was onbord of SMS KÖNIG during the battle of Skagerrak. From 1917 - 1919 with the airship service.

He recieved both ottoman medals during his service at the Feuerwerker school as teacher. Maybe prevent some guys for doing stupid things :-)

Ob.Fwk. Kurt Porske.jpg

Edited by jaba1914

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One more. The group of Oberfeuerwerker Kurt Porske.

In the navy from 1902, serving on many ships (S.M.S. HERTHA, S.M.S. LORELEY, S.M.S. MÜNCHEN, S.M.S. MAGDEBURG, S.M.S. KAISER, S.M.S. PRINZREGENT LUITPOLD, S.M.S. KOENIG). He was onbord of SMS KÖNIG during the battle of Skagerrak. From 1917 - 1919 with the airship service.

He recieved both ottoman medals during his service at the Feuerwerker school as teacher. Maybe prevent some guys for doing stupid things :-)

Ob.Fwk. Kurt Porske.jpg

AH yes, this is a great group! 

Alex, what is the Hamburg cross doing there?  If he earned it, why didn't he represent it on his medal bar and the ribbon bar?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He got the Hamburger and worn it on the medal bar during the war. Later on when he got the Ehrenkreuz he changed it with the Hanseatenkreuz. I have a picture of him wearing this medal bar befor the cross was chaged. Same bar. The Ehrenkreuz was more important for him. 

Regards Alex

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×