Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Romanian Victory Medals


    Recommended Posts

    HI Gents,

    My latest acquisition - the Romanian Official type.

    Hello Bill,

    A nice example of an official type you have obtained. It shows very little wear and is in good condition. Congrats!!

    Finding the award brevets in a correspondingly good condition is a bit more difficult to achieve.

    The ribbon seems to be new - it's very smooth and stiff - and it's a type I haven't seen before. Can anyone say which country it is?

    Any comments welcome.

    Bill

    This ribbon was/is produced in the United States. It is also seen on a number of re-ribboned US vics as well as some of the more recent 'reproductions' that are commonly seen there as well.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Edited by RobW
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 1 month later...
    • Replies 221
    • Created
    • Last Reply

    Top Posters In This Topic

    Top Posters In This Topic

    Posted Images

    Hello Lambert,

    Thanks for posting.

    That is a nice Romanian unofficial variety, with good detail. :)

    You will find that some of the unofficial Romanian varieties are becoming harder to find, with the unofficial type 3a being particularly difficult. They are seen rarely.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Edited by RobW
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hello Rob.

    Thanks for the comment. I'm glad but this medal in my collection. Really liked the fine quality of the medal.

    I did not get an official type, but I'm satisfied with this.

    Only this three missing medals to complete! :o

    Lambert

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 3 weeks later...

    While not the Romanian Inter-Allied Victory medal per se a nice view of a recipient,

    which I recently acquired:-

    Note: He is wearing the Romanian Cross of War backwards to show the dates!

    Kevin in Deva. :jumping:

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    While not the Romanian Inter-Allied Victory medal per se a nice view of a recipient,

    which I recently acquired:-

    Note: He is wearing the Romanian Cross of War backwards to show the dates!

    Kevin in Deva. :jumping:

    Hello Kevin,

    It is difficult to determine from the close-up, and as you have the original photo in hand what category do you assess the vic is?

    * official or unofficial?

    Regards,

    Rob

    Edited by RobW
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Digital photo of the photo.

    In my opinion an Unofficial version of the Romanian Inter-Allied Victory Medal.

    The Romanian Cross of War is the gilt Officers version with the dates "1916 - 1918"

    he has the clasp "1919" which indicates service outside Romanian proper,

    possibly up into Budapest, seeing as the picture is taken by a photographer in Timisoara,

    Western Romania.

    Kevin in Deva.

    Edited by Kev in Deva
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hallo johnnymac, :beer:

    thanks for posting, the second partial picture is very interesting,

    as its the first time I have seen a Romanian Officer sporting the Greek

    Medal of Military Merit 1917. :speechless1:

    Is he named by any chance?

    Kevin in Deva.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Yesterday I came across this documentary on youtube about the saga of a brave warrior Romanian. I would share with you.

    [media=]

    Enjoy

    Lambert

    Edited by lambert
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hallo johnnymac, :beer:

    thanks for posting, the second partial picture is very interesting,

    as its the first time I have seen a Romanian Officer sporting the Greek

    Medal of Military Merit 1917. :speechless1:

    Is he named by any chance?

    Kevin in Deva.

    is really fabulous! :love:

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    In my opinion an Unofficial version of the Romanian Inter-Allied Victory Medal.

    The Romanian Cross of War is the gilt Officers version with the dates "1916 - 1918"

    he has the clasp "1919" which indicates service outside Romanian proper,

    possibly up into Budapest, seeing as the picture is taken by a photographer in Timisoara,

    Western Romania.

    Kevin in Deva.

    Hello Kevin,

    Thanks for the close-up.

    I have attached a combined composite copy of your picture and another from this sub-topic and it suggests that the medal is the unofficial type 2 or 'Reverse N' variety according to the Laslo reference. The unofficial type 3 has certain other distinguishing features that are not the same as that in this picture.

    It is always interesting to see actual pictures of the recipients wearing their medals that we discuss.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 3 months later...

    To all,

    Noting the ongoing conversation regarding a particular Romanian victory medal on the FAKES section I have a comparison to make.

    To bring the conversation back to the medals I have posted another Romanian local victory medal conforming to Alex Laslo's 'unofficial type 3'.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Here is the silvered variety that is causing the discussion over on the other sub-thread.

    A closer inspection of the silvered version shows that, at least the major areas of the obverse and reverse, are very similar. This would suggest a common manufacturer or die.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Edited by RobW
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    And here is a combined composite of the two.

    While there appears to be a reduced level of detail noticeable on the silvered version, especially on the reverse, the common design and features seem to be apparent.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    To All,

    These 5 medals are Romanian medals in my collection. The 6 is the silver medal in question.

    If you look at the letter "M" both 5 & 6 are alike. So alike it hard to believe these were made up as unofficial medals in different places. If you will note the top link of the chain, the rim shape and the ring suspension of both 5 & 6 they match without question as does their letter "M".

    I doubt that silver medal was not being made by Decision No. 847. Even with drawing all these different medal smith each came up with noticeable differences in their final medal, but not number 6 the one in question.

    I trust that all you will agree had medal maker number 5 wanted a medal in silver, he could or would have just stamped one out using his own dies. So why do we find this poor example in silver, was someone faking cast made by using a Number 5 medal?

    Edited by johnnymac
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Although I entered the discussion a little late, and perusing all posts I can conclude, on a personal opnion, the medal "silver Vic Romanian" is an issue "private" a medal copy no-offical type 3 here already mentioned by Robw.

    I believe that this is a "unique item", it is not a scam, I take into consideration that it is possible to be a medal conteporânea the year 20/30.

    . This course, which its defects and its appearance can find disapproval at first, but still has its historical value.

    But it is clear that the price charged by the seller, even thinking that this is an item "valuable" (and is not) and extremely insane for this series. Yes it is an interesting piece that adds in the collection, when properly evaluated and fair price.

    The statement of our colleague Kevin. with competently, proved the existence of numerous variations of local manufacturers Romanians. I agree with Jim in his observation: Officially there are only 2 types of official and other unofficial 3 4 and 5. only .. others are reproductions and copies known .. This exemplor Silver is not recognized as copying or reproduction right? is also not sensible to say that is false until proven otherwise. It is an "independent production" sand casting.

    Best Regards

    Lambert

    Edited by lambert
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hi Gents,

    I've found a couple of interesting threads on a forum about Romanian awards - I see you post to this site as New Connaught Ranger, Kevin.

    First thread is about fake Romanian medals:

    http://www.worldwar2...?showtopic=2250

    And the second shows a 14 medal bar with what I think is an unofficial Victory medal (Type 3?):

    http://www.worldwar2...?showtopic=1130

    Bill

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I believe that this is a "unique item", it is not a scam, I take into consideration that it is possible to be a medal conteporânea the year 20/30.

    . This course, which its defects and its appearance can find disapproval at first, but still has its historical value.

    I would agree Lambert, that this piece does appear to be consistent with others from the same era, and more closely aligns with the 'unofficial type 3' variety.

    The statement of our colleague Kevin. with competently, proved the existence of numerous variations of local manufacturers Romanians. I agree with Jim in his observation: Officially there are only 2 types of official and other unofficial 3 4 and 5. only .. others are reproductions and copies known .. This exemplor Silver is not recognized as copying or reproduction right? is also not sensible to say that is false until proven otherwise. It is an "independent production" sand casting.

    While I have seen other examples where there was a gilt finish, or a much lighter bronze finish, this example was the first one that I have seen with a silvered finish. Without actually holding the example it would be difficult to determine if it is a silvered-bronze example, a zinc derivative, or actually produced in silver.

    Either way it is an interesting example which generated discussion for a week or so. :D

    Regards,

    Rob

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    To All,

    I agree with Bill, that the medal in the grouping might be an unofficial type-3. http://www.worldwar2.ro/forum/index.php?showtopic=1130

    But the question remains: is the silver Romanian medal we have been talking about for 6-7 days just another unofficial type medal covered by decision 847 and was never before reported, and was it used by Romanian veterans or is it a fake? The photo of the Romanian medal in the group, Bill's posted site made reference to, gives that unofficial type-3 medal legitimacy. I also believe there are many other types of unofficial Victory medals from other countries that have not yet been added to the list of unofficial medals.

    Laslo's list is the starting point not ending point. No one that I know has found mention of a silver type victory medal in any documentation from any country. Yet, many of us know the silver colored Victory medals do exist. Were the silver colored ones sold to the general public, so as not to be confused with the medals being issued to or purchased by the veterans? Until real supporting evident is found, such as a photo, I will remain firm in my belief that the silver victory medal is a very questionable medal. Is it collectable," yes", but at what price. This, my friends, is the bottom line for all who collect.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Gents, :beer:

    sorry for the delay in getting to add a reply here, I have busy getting my step-daughter packed up and prepared for a move to Ireland in a week or so.

    My thoughts are as follows:-

    A silver Romanian Inter-Allied Victory Medal medal would not be covered by Decision 847, nearly every type of unofficial Romanian Inter-Allied Victory Medal have been seen as a bronze color or a gilt color, very possible the bronze colored ones were gilted originaly, as gilted versions are prominant on examples of many Romanian Officers bars in the Romanian Military Museum, and single items from WW1 veterans.

    As a "silver" Romanian Victory medal, to my mind, its not an outright fake, but a private purchase / commissioned vanity item, I have seen an examples of The Romanian Cross of War being in gilt for Romanian Officers, where as the other ranks are invairaibly in a bronze color.

    Then we must try to verify is it exactly the same size as the Un-official Type 3, made from the same die and silvered, is it a silver-plated Un-official Type 3 or is it a cast copy in silver?

    I also have come across reference to Romanian Balkan Campain medals being cast in Silver for Romanian officers and having a silver hallmark on the ribbon bar between the leaves of the ribbon Öse, the medal itself being without a maker mark at the 6 o'clock postion on the rim.

    I have also seen a green enameled Romanian Cross of War amongst the collection on exhibition in Timisoara, this too was privately commissioned by the original owner.

    I see price gets mentioned here, a seller can ask anything and hope somebody pays for it. A high price has no bearing on the authenticity of an item, in my honest opinion.

    Kevin in Deva.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Kevin,

    I respect and thank you for the defense of all your thoughts. I truly can see where "you" are coming from. But I am turning out the lights and pulling on this medal to bed. There are no many on this tread who would voice their views so I add again thank you for keeping thinks from becoming boring.

    I'll end by saying if we were ever to meet, let's sit in a cafe and I will order a Brandy Manhattan on the rocks, "light on the vermouth" and salute you a fellow collector, Jim

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    As a "silver" Romanian Victory medal, to my mind, its not an outright fake, but a private purchase / commissioned vanity item, I have seen an examples of The Romanian Cross of War being in gilt for Romanian Officers, where as the other ranks are invairaibly in a bronze color.

    That is, I think the most pertinent point. Given that most other Romanian unofficial strikes have been seen in bronze it is indeed likely that this silver piece was a private purchase or commissioned item.

    Then we must try to verify is it exactly the same size as the Un-official Type 3, made from the same die and silvered, is it a silver-plated Un-official Type 3 or is it a cast copy in silver?

    Given the distinct similarities to other previously identified Romanian unofficial type 3 variants, it is very suggestive of similar dies. While it is likely that such dies were produced by local Romanian artisans it is interesting that this silver piece has found its way to France.

    Regards,

    Rob

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.