-
Posts
1,628 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Store
Everything posted by speedytop
-
EK 1914 EKII 1914: Original or not? Mark?
speedytop replied to Silberstrand's topic in Germany: All Eras: The Iron Cross
-
Maximilian Gritzner on Persians Orders
speedytop replied to JapanX's topic in Middle East & Arab States
Hi James, Persian awards are not my field of knowledge. But: "If he says such different things to different people reading him, he must be wrong somewhere along the line!" ?????? I'm a German, and I'm able to read German. Gritzner wrote nothing like "With the Fifth class the ribbon is blue for Persians, green for foreigners and for "Berfer" ( can't find translation) red or white ribbon." If someone is not able to read and to understand German, especially the old script, see "Berfer" instead of Perser, and others agree with the wrong interpretation, than I think, that we must find another base for discussions. For what is it good, to quote with old regulations in 1836 and 1856, when we are writing here about the Gritzner from 1893. There are new regulations in 1872: "A major modification of the order in 1872 simplified the variety of classes and degrees down to a manageable, five. The differences between awards to foreigners and Persians ceased, though the military and civil divisions and the different coloured ribbons remained." Gritzner wrote in 1893, that the "Löwen- und Sonnenorden" had the same rank system as the French Légion d’honneur (hinsichtlich der Klassen rangierend genau mit denen des französischen Ordens der Ehrenlegion). Therefore it is not the lowest class for a colonel as before, see the regulations from 1836 and 1856! In the here linked sources I cannot find anything, that is against the assignments from Gritzner and Mericka. But I can find a comment about the 1856 firman: "The 1856 firman is extremely confusing in that it tries to deal with the extension and modification of the Order of the Lion and Sun, at the same time as instituting the Decoration of the Royal Portrait. The paragraphs dealing with different matters are often badly set out and intermingled. Even the terminology is frequently haphazard." Uwe -
Maximilian Gritzner on Persians Orders
speedytop replied to JapanX's topic in Middle East & Arab States
Hi James, "So if he is wrong on the L&S, ..." Why is Gritzner wrong on the L&S? We can find the same description in Gritzner (1893) and Mericka (1969): Blue for the court, green for foreigners and red or white for (other) Persian citizens. He don't write anything about the grade of the award in combination with the different colours. Uwe -
Bundesrepublik help with id of 57er pab
speedytop replied to a topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
II. Stufe (25) http://www.ritterkre...auer-Ludwig.pdf Uwe -
Bundesrepublik bundeswehr collection
speedytop replied to a topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
Hi Tom, nice pieces, but please, an officer never wore a "Schützemschnur" (Post3). Uwe -
Bundesrepublik 57er ribbon bar trouble
speedytop replied to a topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
-
DDR Athletic Honorings
speedytop replied to speedytop's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
-
DDR Athletic Honorings
speedytop replied to speedytop's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
-
DDR Signature help
speedytop replied to BURGERHAUS's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
Robert, it is not usual, but you can find it on several documents of the DDR, during all years. The date 23. Oktober 19.. was preprinted, because it was the day of the foundation of the DRK in the DDR (23. Oktober 1952). And the 23. Oktober was the day of the award ceremony. Uwe -
DDR Date of Document
speedytop replied to BURGERHAUS's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
Please see here: http://gmic.co.uk/in...__fromsearch__1 Uwe -
DDR Signature help
speedytop replied to BURGERHAUS's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
Hi BURGERHAUS, It seems, that the document was printed in 1983. From 1981 to 1987 Siegfried Akkermann was the president of the DRK in the DDR. The signature is not original, it is a printed facsimile. Uwe -
Heer Zugwache Set
speedytop replied to Gordon Williamson's topic in Germany: Third Reich: Research, Documentation & Photographs
"In the kind of scenario Chris suggested where maybe the Germans were using a controlled explosion perhaps to clear a blockage on the railway line, any injury would be considered an accident, and the rules clearly stated "Illness and accidents , even if in the face of the enemy, but without intervention of enemy fire, are not eligible for the award" Not correct. Please see here: "Zusätze des Oberkommando des Heeres ... IV. Durchführung der Verleihung ... 2. Verwundung beim Umgang mit Minen: Die Voraussetzungen für die Verleihung des VA. sind als gegeben anzusehen, wenn Soldaten beim Umgang mit eigenen oder feindlichen Minen - Aufnehmen und Entschärfen eigener oder feindlicher Minen oder Blindgänger bzw. Legen oder Verlegen eigener oder fendlicher Minen gegen den Feind - ohne eigenes Verschulden verwundet worden sind. ... OKH., 15.4.43" The conditions for the award of the badge are given, when soldiers without own fault were wounded when dealing with their own or enemy mines. Uwe -
Heer Zugwache Set
speedytop replied to Gordon Williamson's topic in Germany: Third Reich: Research, Documentation & Photographs
Hi, Bei Minensprengung Verletzung des rechten Fußes. > injury of the right foot Chris, "Verletzung" could be both, civilian and military. "Er erlitt bei einem Verkehrsunfall eine schwere Verletzung" > serious injury "Verwundung" is more military, but a "Wunde" (wound) is civilian and military. See in Post 5 on page 34, Im Kriege: Verwundungen und ... "Er hat sich verletzt und hat jetzt eine Wunde am Fuß" "Er wurde verwundet und hat jetzt eine Wunde am Fuß." There is a date difference, 17. Januar and 18. Januar, but that is not unusual. Is there no other entry about his destination after May 1945? Uwe -
Hi redeagle, "... while the one I am showing doesn't" I mean, that I see the dots on your picture in Post 1, especially the right dot: "Ask to the seller to send you close up of the medal and more particulary about the dots." That's right, and I'm convinced, that a better picture will show the dots. Uwe
-
DDR Athletic Honorings
speedytop replied to speedytop's topic in Germany: Post 1945: Bundesrepublik & DDR
-
Paul Julius Hans Tieschowitz v. Tieschowa
speedytop replied to David M's topic in Deutsche Kaiserreich: Man spricht Denglish
Ich kann Dir ein Buch mit der Familie zeigen. Please see here: http://www.degener-a...cd40a1da46.html Uwe