Here is an excellent thread on the USMF - Ed put a lot of effort into this.
https://www.usmilitariaforum.com/forums/index.php?/topic/265973-tiffany-cross-recipients-update-42916/#comment-2139387
Bill
There are 51 TOTAL Navy Medal of Honor recipients between 1919 and 1940 (the Tiffany Cross was first available for award in 1919).
1. Badders - STAR (Confirmed)
2. Balch - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
3. Bennett - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
4. Boone - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
5. Bradley- STAR (Confirmed)
6. Breault- STAR (Confirmed)
7. Button- STAR (Confirmed)
8. Byrd - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
9. Cann - STAR (Confirmed)
10. Cholister - STAR (Confirmed)
11. Corry - UNKNOWN
12. Covington - UNKNOWN
13. Crandall - STAR (Confirmed)
14. Cukela - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
15. Drexler - STAR (Confirmed)
16. Eadie - STAR (Confirmed)
17. Edwards - STAR (Confirmed)
18. Graves - UNKNOWN
19. Hammann - UNKNOWN
20. Hanneken - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
21. Hayden - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
22. Hobson - STAR (Confirmed)
23. Huber - STAR (Confirmed)
24. Hutchins - STAR (Confirmed)
25. Ingram - UNKNOWN
26. Izac - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
27. Janson - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
28. Jones - STAR (Confirmed)
29. Kelly - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
30. Kocak - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
31. Lyle - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
32. MacKinzie - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
33. Madison - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
34. McDonald - STAR (Confirmed)
35. McGunigal - STAR (Confirmed)
36. Mihalowski - STAR (Confirmed)
37. Ormsbee - UNKNOWN
38. Osborne - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
39. Petty - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
40. Pruitt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
41. Robinson - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
42. Ryan - STAR (Confirmed)
43. Schilt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
44. Schmidt - STAR (Confirmed)
45. Siegel - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
46. Smith, Albert - STAR (Confirmed)
47. Stockham - ARMY MOH Awarded
48. Sullivan - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
49. Talbot - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
50. Truesdale - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
51. Upton - STAR (Confirmed)
Of these 51, the following 29 are NOT confirmed recipients of the STAR version of the MOH
1. Balch - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
2. Bennett - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
3. Boone - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
4. Byrd - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
5. Corry - UNKNOWN
6. Covington - UNKNOWN
7. Cukela - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
8. Graves - UNKNOWN
9. Hammann - UNKNOWN
10. Hanneken - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
11. Hayden - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
12. Ingram - UNKNOWN
13. Izac - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
14. Janson - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
15. Kelly - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
16. Kocak - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
17. Lyle - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
18. MacKinzie - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
19. Madison - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
20. Ormsbee - UNKNOWN
21. Osborne - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed)
22. Petty - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
23. Pruitt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
24. Robinson - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
25. Schilt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
26. Siegel - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
27. Sullivan - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
28. Talbot - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
29. Truesdale - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
Of these 29, the following 20 are confirmed Tiffany Cross recipients (or strong evidence indicates a Tiffany Cross recipient)
1. Balch - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
2. Bennett - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
3. Boone - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
4. Byrd - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
5. Cukela - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
6. Hayden - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
7. Izac - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
8. Janson - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed, strong evidence indicates)
9. Kelly - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
10. Kocak - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed, strong evidence indicates)
11. Lyle - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
12. Madison - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
13. Osborne - TIFFANY CROSS (NOT Confirmed, strong evidence indicates)
14. Petty - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
15. Pruitt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
16. Robinson - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
17. Schilt - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
18. Siegel - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
19. Sullivan - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
20. Talbot - TIFFANY CROSS (Confirmed)
That leaves 9 recipients as follows:
1. Corry - UNKNOWN
2. Covington - UNKNOWN
3. Graves - UNKNOWN
4. Hammann - UNKNOWN
5. Hanneken - STAR (NOT Confirmed, strong evidence indicates)
6. Ingram - UNKNOWN
7. MacKinzie - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
8. Ormsbee - UNKNOWN
9. Truesdale - STAR (NOT Confirmed)
OK, that is the current status of the Tiffany Cross recipients. It was just time to update everyone.