Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Medalla "Por la Victoria Cuba R.P.A."


    Stogieman

    Recommended Posts

    • 6 months later...

    Award Critaria

    Awarded in recognition of the outstanding attitude maintained during the fulfillment of the International mission asked of them, in defense of the revoulutionary conquests in Angola and in the interest of its sovereignty and territorial integrity.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • 4 months later...
    • 3 months later...
    • 8 months later...

    An interesting book review:

    From: H-Net Staff <hbooks@mail.h-net.msu.edu>

    Date: Wednesday, December 24, 2008 8:32:35 AM

    Subject: H-Net Review Publication: 'A Russian View of the Angolan War'

    Igor Zhdarkin. We Did Not See It Even in Afghanistan. Moscow

    Memories Mockba, 2008. Translated by Tamara Reilly. 399 pp.

    Reviewed by Elaine Windrich

    Published on H-SAfrica (November, 2008)

    Commissioned by Peter C. Limb

    A Russian View of the Angolan War

    This book is to be welcomed as an alternative to the usual accounts

    of the Angolan War by South African participants and their

    apologists. For here is a Russian version, by a military officer,

    Igor Zhdarkin, who served as an advisor/translator to the Angolan

    armed forces known as FAPLA (For?as Armadas Populares de

    Liberta??o de Angola), the military wing of the ruling Popular

    Movement for the Liberation of Angola (MPLA). His account is

    published as part of a collection of memoirs in the series Oral

    History of Forgotten Wars by the Africa Institute of the Russian

    Academy of Sciences in Moscow. Unfortunately, in the introduction,

    Gennady Shubin, senior research fellow at the institute, does not

    indicate what other ?forgotten wars? are to be included in the

    series or why they have been so labeled.

    The English section of Zhdarkin's recollections (consisting of the

    final 150 pages of the 400-page book, the first part of which

    comprises the Russian version) consists of two major parts: a diary

    kept by Zhdarkin from October 10 to December 3, 1987, as military

    interpreter of the 2lst FAPLA brigade, and the author?s ?oral

    narratives,? or tape-recorded memories, produced at the Africa

    institute since 2000-01. Unfortunately, the ?Notebook-Diary? in

    part 1 is a great disappointment because the author?s daily

    ?recollections? come to an abrupt end in December 1987, before

    the crucial battles for Cuito Cuanavale had even begun. As his final

    entry (dated December 3) reads, ?our brigade is in its positions in

    the forest. We are awaiting a possible enemy attack and we have no

    idea of what will happen next? (p. 302). Nor does the reader know

    what happened next, since Zhdarkin disappears from the scene of

    battle, only to return to Cuito Cuanavale after the South African

    Defence Force?s (SADF) initial assaults on the ?Tempo Triangle?

    have been rebuffed in 1988. None of these decisive battles, which are

    recorded in great detail in the South African accounts of the war

    (irrespective of their triumphant distortions), are mentioned by

    Zhdarkin. Only in a later commentary does he explain that he returned

    to Cuito Cuanavale on March 11, 1988 (after more than two months at

    the FAPLA base at Lobito), adding only that, ?I cannot say why I

    returned. But I was summoned there? (p. 368). Then, from the final

    reading in the diary, the book leaps into the ?author

    commentaries? recorded in Moscow from 2000, separated only by a

    song written by Zhdarkin in Cuito Cuanavale in December 1987.

    Even with this abrupt ending of the diary, the daily entries should

    not to be underrated, since they contain a vivid account of the 1987

    battles for the control of the Uni?o Nacional para a Independ?ncia

    Total de Angola (UNITA) stronghold of Mavinga, which reached a climax

    at the crossing of the Lomba River toward the end of that year. For

    this is where FAPLA was forced to withdraw under heavy bombardment by

    the SADF, which had intervened to save their UNITA ally from

    annihilation. Once again, UNITA leader Jonas Savimbi claimed the

    victory for his forces, and even his U.S. benefactor, President

    Ronald Reagan, intervened with a message of congratulations for the

    ?heroes of the Lomba River.?

    But none of these particular events are recalled in the book as the

    diary opens with the retreat from the Lomba River crossing. From

    there, Zhdarkin and the 2lst brigade began their long march to join

    the other FAPLA brigades, which were regrouping in the aftermath of

    the disastrous rout to prepare for the defense of their key base at

    Cuito Cuanavale. The retreat was indeed a harrowing experience, as

    the title of the book reveals, since FAPLA troops were under

    continual bombardment by the SADF, along with the sniping, mining,

    and other harassment by the UNITA forces on the ground. As the author

    relates, even the Russians who had served in Afghanistan had never

    experienced such ?horrors? as the barrage of SADF artillery

    across the Lomba River. Under fire from the G-6 guns and the Mirage

    and Buccaneer aircraft, FAPLA brigades panicked and deserted the

    field in flight, leaving behind their Soviet equipment in a graveyard

    of tanks, trucks, ammunition, and other materiel. At one stage of the

    retreat (according to Zhdarkin), they were even bombed with

    ?chemical weapons containing poisonous gas,? against which they

    had no gas masks for protection (p. 269). Finally, and after nearly

    two months of retreating under fire, the author was able to join the

    Soviet advisors of the 59th and 16th brigades awaiting the defense of

    Cuito Cuanavale.

    The commentaries that constitute the second part of the book contain

    a wide range of subjects, beginning with an account of the training

    and preparation of Soviet advisors for service in Angola and ending

    with an explanation for the Angolan defeat in 1987. In between, the

    author reveals his views of the participants in the conflict,

    including FAPLA, South Africans, and Cubans, and the Soviet

    advisors? interactions with them. Some commentaries are in the form

    of questions to and answers from the author, including those that a

    tourist or visitor might ask, such as the prevalence of snakes (how

    many did you see?) and alcoholic beverages (how much did they

    drink?). But many more questions are concerned with the types of

    Soviet weapons used and their effectiveness for the Angolan terrain,

    which are shown in the photographs in the book.

    The most revealing commentaries are those concerning the author?s

    opinion of the participants. On first impressions of Angola, he found

    Luanda ?more horrible? than other places he had visited. ?Just

    a pile of ######,? he described it, as he viewed ?the dirty airport

    and the ragged women and children on the floor? (a scene also

    observed by this reviewer) and the piles of rubbish covering the

    streets of Luanda (p. 314). As for the Angolan soldiers, they were

    ?unsuitable for war.? Not only were they ?afraid to take part

    in combat actions,? they were also unwilling to follow the

    ?reasonable advice? of their Soviet advisors (p. 341).

    Consequently, it was necessary for the advisors to tell the Angolans

    that they were wrong and beat them up accordingly. As the author

    explains, because many Soviet advisors were not familiar with ?the

    peculiarities of the black Angolan mentality,? they often found it

    difficult to relate to them and obtain results (pp. 312-313).

    In contrast, the author does not say anything ?bad? about the

    South Africans. ?They fought well and competently because they were

    whites, because I myself am white and because South Africa related to

    us as whites to whites? (p. 369). He was also impressed by the

    ?ultimatum? delivered to Soviet soldiers inside the shells fired

    by the SADF artillery: ?Soviets, leave Cuito Cuanavale. We don?t

    want to touch you--our so-called white brothers. We want to cut up

    the Angolans? (p. 363).

    The most effusive praise was rightly reserved for the Cubans, without

    whom the author would not have survived to record these memoirs. It

    was the Cubans who had supplied them, fought and died for Angola, and

    forced South Africa to sue for peace after having allegedly destroyed

    most of their tanks and driven the SADF out of Angolan and back over

    the Namibian border. In effect, ?the Cubans did everything of

    importance? to ensure that the defense of Cuito Cuanvale would

    succeed after the disastrous retreat from the Lomba River described

    in the diary (p. 379). Above all, they tried to persuade the Soviet

    advisors that they must ?adapt? to the Angolan soldiers on whom

    they relied and not judge the situation in Angola as if it were the

    Soviet Union (p. 379).

    The book ends with an addendum on the memoirs of South African Chief

    of Staff General Jannie Geldenhuys in which Zhdarkin doubts the

    accuracy of the general?s tally of South African gains and losses

    during the fighting in Angola in 1987-88. This is scarcely surprising

    since the purpose of the general?s account was to convey the

    impression that the SADF not only won the war but also brought

    ?peace? by fighting it. This is followed by two appendices, one

    an extensive collection of photographs of participants and military

    equipment and the other a note recording the names of the Soviet

    military advisors who had served in Angola since November 1975, of

    whom there were thousands of servicemen and officers, including

    generals, admirals, and ?civil specialists.?

    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons

    Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States

    License.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.