Jump to content
Stojan

False and original pieces of the German army

Recommended Posts

Hello, I have this badge of hand-to-hand combat, the seller assured me it is original, but I would like to know other opinions, I would appreciate someone telling me what you think.

Best regards.IMG_20180119_143209722-3120x2340.thumb.jpg.5bc81ff8ce71d0e3445d71518c6d9c8c.jpgIMG_20180119_143214537-3120x2340.thumb.jpg.b1308018efcd8706c063108eeb0d74ea.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a fake....

Original close Combat clasps by F&BL (Funcke & Brüninghaus, Ludenscheid) has the maker mark above the clasp and is upside down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have seen for sale in Germany this badge of the kriegsmarine, they gave it to the dwarf submarines etc ... in the period of 1944-1945.

What I would like to know is if the badge is from 1944-1945 or if it is from 1957, since many badges of this type were made in 1957.

It's from C.E Juncker

Screenshot_20180122-170223.png

Screenshot_20180122-170227.png

Screenshot_20180122-170238.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Original wartime issued examples of these Small Battle Units War Badges are extremely rare and have certain characteristics which this one does not have... nor does it have the typical reverse setup (hinge/catch/pin) of a 1957 issued piece.  

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sadly, it was the case as long ago as the 1990s that a significant percentage of the 'WWII German' badges, particularly the rarer ones but even many common issues, were outright fakes, had been assembeled after the war from genuine parts or were in some other way 'not as advertised.'  I don't know nearly enough to guess what % of today's items fall into these categories but I would be very very careful were I to start collecting in this field. :(

Edited by peter monahan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, J Temple-West said:

  The original examples issued during the war of these War Badges of the Small battle units are extremely rare and have certain characteristics that this one does not have ... nor does it have the option to return to the typical left (hinge / capture / pin) of a piece issued in 1957.

 

 

 

-So the badge is not from 1957 or from 1944-45?

Edited by Stojan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi, Stojan

The difference between wartime pieces and those produced in 1957 is that the fins are not ribbed on those of the 1944 design.

The 1957 design, having ribbing on the fins, shows that the badge that you've posted is based on the 1957 design but has a maker mark for C.E Juncker.  The Juncker factory was destroyed in late 1944 which means that either this is a one-off piece produced in 1957 with a totally different reverse set-up to the those found on most 1957 badges and with a fake post-war maker mark for Juncker.

With all these red flags, I would have to give an opinion that this badge was produced to deceive.

As a point of interest, there has only been one documented original 1944 'Small Battle Units War Badges badge' sold on the open market and that was in 1998 by a dealer in Germany....this shows how rare they are.   

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

I don't understand the connection with: "made in 1957". It could be an original or a copy/reproduction/fake. If it is a copy, it could be made in 1953 or 1960. Such a piece have nothing to do with the 1957er decorations, if is meant that.

Uwe

Edited by speedytop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good morning, Uwe

As the badge in question is of the 1957 design, it would have to have been produced after 1957....when is any body's guess.

these 1957 type badges are still produced today and can be found for as little as £/E/$ 35.00 on auction sites.

Again, as a point of interest... the picture shown below is the only known original example of a Small Battle Units War Badge that came from the estate of Ottfried Neubecker, the designer of the award. As can be seen, the fins of the sawfish are smooth.

 

1944.JPG.46e5ee0ccd8218d8c5d8ebe672b375a9.JPG                                                            

 

compared to an example of a typical 1957 series piece.. As can be seen, the fins are ribbed.

(photo from an article by Gordon Williamson) 

1957.jpg.613688b4332a617d89ff41fbcbbf63fe.jpg

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi John,

I don't understand that: "As the badge in question is of the 1957 design, ..."

This piece is not a 1957er decoration, and such copies had been made several years before the law from 1957 (and of course after 1957).

Uwe

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

The Kleinkampfverbände clasp with Juncker maker's mark is quite common modern cast fake, so is the case. As John has already said there is only one example known that is thought to be an original sample piece and it comes from the designer of this clasp. It is the one posted by John. I enclose another image of the same sample piece. It was sold by several prominent dealers over the years. Last time it was offered by Lothar Hartung for 7800 eur in 2004.There is no evidence that any of these were manufactured before the end of the war.

Cheers,

Hubert

6.Stufe.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IMO the last clasp shown in this thread is original. And as far as I know, the only known. Very nice!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Blog Comments

    • Thanks for your reply Patrick, just in case some might not know what the Belgian WW1 Medal you were referencing looks like I have included one here. I understand that the small crown on the ribbon denoted the recipient was a volunteer.  
    • Brian, Thanks for initiating this discussion. For me, it’s a combination of the thrill of the chase, the history behind the item, and the aesthetics, although this latter factor may seem a bit strange to some. To illustrate this, the very first thing I collected as a kid in the 1950’s was a Belgian WW1 medal, for service in 1914-18, which is bell shaped, with a very striking profile of a very dignified soldier, wearing an Adrian helmet which bears a laurel wreath. It was the image that
    • Thank you for sharing your story, it was most interesting and greatly appreciated, it makes this blog well worth the time to post. Regards Brian  
    • Hello I started collecting when I found my first Mauser cartridges in a field next to my parents' house next to Armentières. I was eight years old.  Then shrapnel, schrapnell balls, darts... That's how I became a historian. When I was 18, we used to walk through the fields with a metal detector to find our happiness. It was my time in the army as a research-writer in a research centre that made me love the orders of chivalry. I've been collecting them for 24 years now. Christophe
    • Thank you for your most interesting comment. The thrill of the chase didn't interest me in the beginning but over time it started to overshadow the act of simply adding yet another medal or group to the collection. Regards Brian  
×
×
  • Create New...