5tefan

.

Hello ;-)

What is your opinion ?

Hello Everybody

I was just wondering if anyone can confirm if 51 Eduard Goriach & Sohne Gablonz/N. made EK1's. Or is a 39 EK1 marked 51 considered to be a fake? If there are originals can anyone please post a picture for comparison purposes.

Cheers

Chris

mm 51 is a fake!!! Attached you will see the one and only mm for EK1

1 Deschler und Sohn3 Wilhelm Deumer4 Steinhauer & Lueck6 Fritz Zimmermann7 Paul Meybauer11 Wilhelm Deumer15 F. Orth, Wien (L15)19 E. Ferdinand Wiedmann, Frankfurt am Main20 C.F. Zimmermann21 Gebr. Godet22 Boerger & Co., Berlin24 Arbeitsgemeinsch, Hanau26 B.H. Mayer, Pforzheim65 Klein & Quenzer100 Rudolf Waechtler107 Carl WildL/10 Deschler und SohnL/11 Wilhelm DeumerL/12 C.E. JunckerL/13 Paul MeybauerL/14 Friedrich Orth, Wien (Souval Rahmen)L/15 Otto SchickleL/16 Steinhauer & LueckL/18 B.H. Mayer'sL/19 Ferdinand HoffstaetterL/50 Gebr. GodetL/52 C.F. ZimmermannL/53 HymmenL/54 Schaueret & HoehfeldL/55 Waechtler u. LangeL/56 Funcke & BruenninghausL/57 Boerger & Co.L/58 Rudolf SouvalL/59 Alois Rettenmaier

..

.

What do you see?

..

.

:cheers:

Hi Stefan,

i have never seen a cross like yours before. I don`t know if this cross is original or fake.

Maybe the pin was replaced ?

Sorry, but i can`t help you for the moment...

Regards,

Oliver

Hi Oliver ;-)

If you compare the frame with the EK1 round 3 from the following link:

http://gmic.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=1730

You will see that my frame matched to the other frames!

Maybe the other pinsystem cover the Backside hole ;-)

So could it be a 22 Boerger & Co., Berlin with none round 3 and ohter type of pinsystem?

..

.

What do you think about it?

...

..

.

What do you see?

Is it a II.WW production?

.

.

What do you see?

No comment after 4 houres? I'm little bit disapointed!

..

.

What is your opinion?

I have seen now two EK1 L/15 with the mm stamp on his head!

Is that OK ???