Hello Everyone. It's been 9 years, but I am back! I was finally able to locate the original image and made some high-res scans. The Google Docs link below has the new copies, though still blurry. Hopefully this will help identify the unit.
Again, this is John Joseph Kelly born 1871 Athlone, Westmeath, Ireland. He went to the US, arriving in 1891.
High Res Images: https://photos.app.goo.gl/2jAEKpBL4q8s5WYW7