Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Ed_Haynes

    For Deletion
    • Posts

      14,343
    • Joined

    • Last visited

    • Days Won

      25

    Posts posted by Ed_Haynes

    1. It is most disturbing that a fellow human would murder another for a medal. One German online dealer has a site for crime and it is shocking :speechless1: . In the States I don't think we have that problem, perhaps the bad guys have no desire to cross oceans or face the possibility of Americans keeping guns in their homes. Under your scenario vaults are meaningless and you have a valid point. Let us hope the bad guys don't come ashore.

      Well . . . after the targeted robbery that Markov suffered (no one was harmed, but was that mere luck?) . . . ????

      Guns?? Ha ha ha. What a hormonal joke. Better for snuffing college students or hamburger customers.

    2. Honestly, the historical content of this one puts any Charge of the Light Brigade group to shame. Repeat after me: "Potemkin". (Though a bit more evidence would be a nice touch, it seems kosher.) And, even though it is far outside my field, I can see that.

      But, then, some would rather have 3,516 (more or less) essentially identical and totally history-free 1914 EK2s?

      Whatever gets you through the night?

    3. I think that for this price, one could buy an original collar (in gold, 2nd half 19th Century) of the Austrian Golden Fleece, and there would still remain some money in the pocket to go to the cinema...

      Enzo

      True. I guess.

      And you could also (almost) buy a VC group (if Lord Ashcan weren't in the bidding).

      So???

      Much less history in the collar and the VC group would at least be named (though it too, for that much money, wouldn't have too much history connected with it).

    4. But did he really say "Nuts!" ? I have read suggestions that the actual answer was two words, the first of which has some of the same letters as "FiretrUCK" and the second of which rhymes with "toff". The suggestion, plus the notion that the history had to be cleaned up for public consumption in 1945, struck me as very plausible. Also quite in character for a hard-charging yank officer in the circumstances and a little more forceful, shall we say, than "Nuts."

      Has anyone else heard this suggestion? Of course, having read it 20+ years ago I have no recollection of the source, though I believe the author of the book had spoken to survivors of Bastogne, possibly even the author of the famed remark. Comments?

      Peter

      I have heard the same thing, including in stories recounted by a family friend who was there. But once a myth gets established, especially a "clean" myth, . . . .

    5. I might be wrong, and that's why I would appreciate other members opinions (including Lapa), but to me, it seems there was a number "6" at the right of current serial number. First photo is the one that was posted here, second is the same photo in negative colors.

      Does it look like a 6 or I am being paranoid?

      Good eyes. To me, that does look . . . well . . . troublesome (or worse).

    6. Interesting, William. #2082 is way (WAY) beyond the maximum recorded for a normal silver pinback (which is #2006), and well into the range for what I think is a fraudulently named nasty-brassy Sukhbaatar (the only one recorded is #2057, which I doubt). I'd want a close sniff at that one . . . .

      Any idea what the #2082 was???

    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.