-
Posts
520 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Store
Posts posted by censlenov
-
-
After a long break from this thread i have begun to catch up on writing articles on the pieces i've added to the collection over the past 2 years. I'll try to add one or two a week and that should get me caught up in about 3 months .
Cheers
Chris
0 -
From that pic i'd say it looks promising. I don't want to say for sure based on such a small picture but i do see some good signs.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Single BWM to The RN and RNAS are not that uncommon. So Naval service makes sense. The photo makes sense also and his entitlement is very logical given his standing in the fire service. I believe his full group will be OBE, KPFSM, BWM, Def medal, 37 coronation, and 53 coronation.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Here's the naggin thought in my mind. "Le Gaulois" was sunk Dec of 1916. Why was an award for Le Gaulois in a 1918 roll. hmmmmmmm............ A possible scenario though poorly noted in the roll is that the second medal is a replacement for the 1st which went down on the Gaulois. This is a pretty common scenario and i've seen it in other instances. Are these the only two dsm rolls to french recipients or are there others?
Cheers
Chris
0 -
If you can prove he died 25+ years ago you can get his service file under the FOI act. It's a running topic at the britishmedalsforum and many members including myself have had great results.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Not looking so good things are going pear shaped. It's a long story and I'm not sure how things are going to pan out the next few wees will be telling.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Sure thing Chris. I am pretty busy right now (as i'm sure 99% of us are) but i hope to pick it up over the week i have off at Christmas. Thankys for your help.
cheers
Chris
0 -
Had an interesting lunch break encounter today with an old collector and we got to talking. One thing led to another and badda bing badda boom next thing i know i'm a buying a 1918 dated MG08/15. Once i pick it up i'll post photos but can anyone give me a conservative estimate as to value as i am way out of my element. It's in decent shape not a relic. I'm sure photos will help with the valuation but i'd like to get a sense as to how i did.
It may look out of place surrounded by my "Medicine Hat" militaria collection. But i suspect it may fit in with more research.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Just stumbled on this sorry for being late to the party
His MSM was in the LG
Gazette Issue 31167 published on the 4 February 1919. page 1945
Nice group luckily a replacement leopold will be easy to get your hands on. I should post my ED group to a local veteran (just got it last week and it's the first one i've ever managed to find).
Cheers
Chris
0 -
This bar is on my hand and have been fixed!
I wonder which division does this medal bar belong to? Can it be Ghurka's?
Defence medal's criteria is for 'non-operational service', so this bar belongs to an instructor/admin/airfield crew?
I think it's almost impossible researching an individual who got this bar because no name on the stars and this is a common bar, isn't it?
So this is my summary:
This man (army,navy, or airforce) was served on a division in Burma/Malaya/Sumatra/Bengal; he was on non-operational service (an instructor/airfield crew/admin/other)
Any opinions?
Windu
Yes unfortunately impossible to research. very common combination I suspect most likely army or airforce. But i don't agree he was on non operational service he was for a time to qualify for the defence medal but that doesn't mean that he did take part in any operations against the enemy after qualifying for that medal. Quite afew canadian groups have a defence medal and the men post June 44 went on to serve in france and germany.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
I believe this medal may be a replacement issue. WW1 awards were actually impressed (but not in the style of ww1 campaign medals). This style of naming is consistent with ww2 naming and i'm NOT 100% certain this has been named. His service file should be able to clear up the late issue/replacement issue.
cheers
Chris
0 -
Yes bad news the F&G is bad (lots wrong with it most glaring obvious is the VI as its not serifed) the aircrew may be and from the overall photo there is some red flags that go up on afew others. Would individual obverse pics be available for review?
Cheers
Chris
0 -
theres one to the 27th Maine on emedals right now and afew others......
honestly as long as someone honours the memory of the recipient then i don't see any problem with these medals changing hands over the years. As for specimens i just don't see a problem at all. The problem is the yahoos who act as though they are entitled to them when they aren't these walts should be dealt with harshly.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
I'd love to read that book also
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Waste of cash in my opinion....... that could have bought a very nice researchable CEF Gallantry group very sad.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Is it me or does that badge give you the impression it was of asian manufacture. The horse and rider look stylisticly like something one would see in asian art work. Sounds weird and i hope i don't come across sounding wrong but it looks like a chinese manufacturer made a copy of a russian badge. Certainly not of the quality i would expect.
cheers
Chris
0 -
I thought about that and based on what i saw over lunch it could be a civil award of the obe mbe as some were given to RN personnel. I just can't find any VC recipients of an order of the rising sun.
Chris
0 -
I've been watching this develop and i'm thinking the last bar posted is
medal of the order of the british empire, DSC, Japanese order of the rising sun
I'll see if i can find a match
Cheers
Chris
0 -
If you post the recipient i can confirm the clasps for you if you'd like. Or is it Simon Fuzzy?
Cheers
Chris
0 -
This has been shown before on the forum when it was posted on eBay for sale. I can't find the thread right now but the owner couldn't be pinned down at the time (although i probably can now). It would be a unique set of awards. I can't remember what the owner was asking on eBay but it was too much. Check the DNW auction archive to get comparable results it would be the best way to gauge market trend.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Do you have any info on Edward J Wallof he was born in Redcliff Alberta Canada and was a usmc fighter pilot awarded the NC in ww2. I'm trying to find out where he wound up after the war and if he is still alive.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
There is a version with no inner circles but as for the paint i'd have to say it was someone idea of trying to gussy an item up. The maker mark on the back gives it away as being an American piece.
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Its not an iron cross it's an American Weapons Qualification badge. The hanger suspends the name of the weapons qualification.
Check out this ebay auction
Cheers
Chris
0 -
Nice pic i love these guessing games
Cheers
Chris
0
Some CEF Groups in my collection
in Great Britain: Orders, Gallantry, Campaign Medals
Posted · Edited by censlenov
466206 Pte. Arthur Thomas Trotman 63rd/10th Canadian Infantry Battalion CEF
In the spring of 1915 Medicine Hat was in the process of preparing to recruit its own infantry battalion to add to the pool of men traveling over the Atlantic and trudging into the trenches in France. A battalion of mounted rifles had just left the City in June when a request for recruits came from Edmonton. The 63rd Infantry Battalion Headquartered in Edmonton was having trouble filling its ranks and needed more men. The job fell to the recruiters in Medicine Hat to fill “D” Company of the 63rd and it was a job they did well.
On July 2nd 1915 Arthur Thomas Trotman entered the recruiting office and attested for service in the Canadian Expeditionary Force. Trotman was not born in Canada he was from Bisley Glouchestershire in England birthed on September 11th 1884. He immigrated to Canada and first was recorded living in Medicine Hat in 1911. Arthur lived in a suite at 341 3rd Street SE by himself and worked as a general labourer for a Mr. B Roberts. His medical examination at the time of his enlistment describes him as 5’ 7 ½” tall, of a medium build, with a medium complexion, Blue eyes, and Dark Brown hair.
When the ranks of “D” Company filled and the Battalion had undergone some initial training in Canada Arthur proceeded east to the disembarkation port of St. John New Brunswick where he hunkered down aboard the SS Metagama for the journey to England. The ship left port on April 22nd 1916 and arrived in England on the 5th of May.
In England the 63rd proceeded to Shorncliffe where the battalion was disbanded and its troops were placed into the 11th Reserve Battalion on June 4th. By June 6th Trotman was assigned to the 10th Infantry Battalion and on the 8th he had arrived in France and proceeded to join his new unit.
The Battle of Mount Sorrel had just taken place on June 3rd. It was another unsuccessful assault; the counter-attack by the 10th was launched against a small knoll in the Ypres. There were considerable losses suffered and despite the relatively low height of this feature, it provided an excellent viewpoint over flat terrain in the area and was of considerable strategic importance. The 10th would not see another major action until near the end of the Somme campaign.
The 10th Battalion was involved in a series of operations from 8 September and 17 October, primarily defensive actions which were successful, north of Albert, France near the town of Boiselle. A successful defensive battle fought by the 10th Battalion, during the Somme Campaign, near the town of Albert, France was “Ancre Heights”. Modest casualties were suffered during the action on 10–11 September 1916. On 26 September 1916 an action took place at the Thiepval Ridge, near the town of Courcelette. The offensive operation was considered a success for the 10th Battalion, at the cost of 241 casualties.
One of the wounded during the Thiepval Ridge battle was Arthur Trotman he had been shot in the left arm. After receiving preliminary treatment in France he was taken back to England for additional treatment and recuperation. After his arrival in England he was first transferred to Canadian Casualty Assembly Center (CCAC) Fokestone on October 2nd and from there was sent to Bagthorpe Military Hospital in Nottingham. Following a two month stay he was transferred to Canadian Convalescent Hospital (CCH) Hillingdon in the township of Uxbridge on the 14th of December.
On the 13th of February 1917 after completion of his convalescence Arthur Trotman was assigned to Garrison Duty Depot (GDD) Hastings. His wound had left him unacceptable for front line service but still able enough to perform more menial tasks. A little over two weeks later on the 28th he was assigned to 33 Company 3rd District Canadian Forestry Corps.
The Canadian Forestry Corps (CFC) was created on the 14th of November 1916. It was discovered that huge quantities of wood were needed for use on theWestern Front. Wood was used to build duckboards, shoring timbers, crates, etc. The British government concluded that there was nobody more experienced or qualified in the British Empire to harvest timber than the Canadians. At first the idea was to harvest the trees from Canada's abundant forests and bring them overseas. However, space aboard merchant ships was at a premium and so rather than stuff ships' holds with timber; it was decided to use the Canadians over in Europe to cut down forests in the UK and France.
Arthur continued to serve in the CFC and on July 2nd he was awarded a good conduct badge. He was transferred to the 4th district in September and the 5th district in November. Following the end of hostilities Trotman was transferred to the CFC depot on November 23rd 1918. From there he proceeded to Canadian Discharge Depot (CDD) Buxton on December 4th. By the 15th of December he was on his way back to Canada. Arthur Thomas Trotman was officially discharged at Calgary on February 14th 1919.
Not much else can be found out about Arthur Trotman after the war only that he lived to be 98 years old. He died at Shaughnessy Hospital, Vancouver, British Columbia on February 23, 1983.
For his service in the war he was awarded the British War Medal 14-18 and Inter-allied Victory Medal.