Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Recommended Posts

    Posted (edited)

    Some time ago I was luckily able to purchase off a medal collector some of my ancestor's war medals (which came to my attention out of the blue - he didn't know until I'd bought them they were my ancestor's). To my knowledge he'd been awarded the QSA (with clasps), 1914-15 Star, BWM, and VM.

    The medals I purchased was the BWM, VM and a GSM with Kurdistan Clasp.

    The GSM confused me because according to his RAF records he'd "relinquished commission" on 9th January 1919 - which is before the qualification dates to earn an GSM with Kurdistan Clasp.

    Is it possible someone (maybe my ancestor) took an erased GSM and had his name impressed on it?

    Hopefully the photos attached will help draw a conclusion?

    Many thanks,

    Giles56be4a1e9f0f3_20160212_205816(2).thumb.j56be4a1ccb9f8_20160212_205806(2).thumb.j56be4a1b08806_20160212_205743(2).thumb.j56be4a1948832_20160212_205738(2).thumb.j56be4a17c51ff_20160212_205724(2).thumb.j56be4a1479dce_20160212_205622(2).thumb.j56be4a160692f_20160212_205649(2).thumb.j56be4a133d8fa_20160212_205533(2).thumb.j56be4a11d20bb_20160212_205525(2).thumb.j56be4a102996a_20160212_205517(2).thumb.j

     

    Edited by gilesforrest
    Typo
    Posted

    Here's some other George V GSM engraved names for comparison - it appears some variety of font style and spacing is possible. The first few medals pictured below have the greatest similarity in terms of font:

    img_04.jpg5357d4bf91615.jpg

    img_03.jpg5395f30f5993c.jpg

    img_03.jpg53ea226943816.jpg

    img_03.jpg554504dc7c1a6.jpg

    img_03.jpg5314f99638942.jpg

    img_04.jpg535ab4cfe9db5.jpg

    img_03.jpg53ea1f4c109f1.jpg

    15.jpg511026fb8f48f.jpg

    img_2849_copy.jpg

    img_03.jpg53ed099bbd1eb.jpg

     

    img_03.jpg55915c6a05f87.jpg

     

    Posted

    Don't quote me, but I seem to recall that Indian army GSMs were minted in India and are slightly thinner than the British army GSMs which were minted in the UK.

     

    To me your RAF GSM seems genuine, HOWEVER, the scratches/dints on the RAF portion, would need closer inspection, possibly renamed? But I'm no expert. 

    Posted

    Without a detailed and enlarged version of the naming it is impossible to be absolutely certain but I can't see anything obviously wrong. The Indian issues were struck in Calcutta and vary from the British.

    Paul

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.