Dave Danner

For some reason I can't see your attachments. Is anyone else having this problem? Here is Smilo Freiherr von Lüttwitz: and Friedrich Foertsch:

Unfortunately, none of these four pan out from the regimental rolls. None got the Baden decoration. 1) Gefreiter Karl Böttner of 3rd Company Kurt Böttner, born 22.4.1891 in Sonneberg, S-M, Kaufmann in Würzburg. Promoted to Unteroffizier on 7.3.1918 24.8.1916 Bavarian Military Merit Cross 3rd Class with Swords (BMV5cX) 8.11.1917 SMM 23.3.1918 Bavarian DA 3. Klasse (BDA3) 19.5.1918 EK2 2) Gefreiter Friedrich Dreßler of 6th Company Friedrich Karl Dressler, born 30.9.1890 in Saalfeld a/Saale, Schreiner in Munich. 27.2.1916 SMM (A.E. v. 27.2.16 Ihr. K. Hoh. der Frau Herzogin Charlotte v. Sachs.-Meiningen) 19.1.1918 EK2 (Verf. d. 14.b.I.D. No. 275/IIa) 3) Gefreiter Artur Jakob of 9th Company Arthur Jakob, born 30.1.1891 in Beuern, Schalkau, S-M. Promoted to Unteroffizier on 10.5.1916, transferred to bay. 22.IR on 7.6.1917 11.6.1916 EK2 20.8.1916 SMM (maybe 28.8.1916) 14.10.1916 BMV5cX 4) Unteroffizier dR Christian Kallenbach of 9th Company Christian Kallenbach, born 17.5.1889 in Leimbach, S-M., Schneider in Leimbach. Promoted to Sergeant on 12.3.1918. 11.11.1916 EK2 1.2.1918 SMM 2.8.1918 Verw.Abz.schw. 4.4.1918 BDA3

He is still listed in the 15. April 1918 Bavarian rank list for active officers. Would that have been the case if invalided out?

And the reverse:

Crisper images:

Hptm. Holler survived the war. He was char. as a Maj. a.D. with permission to wear the uniform of 17.IR on 26. Okt. 1920. Regards, Dave

Alois Holler was promoted to Oberleutnant in mid-1914. He received the BMV4X on 30.11.14. He received his BZ3bX in March 1915 while still with 8.IR (whose Inhaber was the Grand Duke of Baden). He was killed in action as a Hauptmann on 7.4.17 at Arras (St. Laurent), while still serving with 8.IR.

Seven people were awarded four Navy Crosses in World War II: Samuel Dealey, Eugene Fluckey, Slade Cutter, Glynn Donaho, Anton Gallaher, Harold Mazza and Dudley Morton. Roy Davenport was awarded five Navy Crosses. Chesty Puller also received five Navy Crosses, but these were in three different conflicts (Nicaragua (2), WW2 (2) and Korea). Preston and Vejtasa don't show up in the Social Security Death Index, though Vejtasa's wife appears to have died in 2004.

By the way, Paul's example is interesting. Even though Schmidt was a Bavarian officer, both his Bavarian awards came well after his Prussian ones. Even the two Mecklenburg-Schwerin awards, which he got because the Grand Duke was Inhaber of the Bavarian 21st Infantry Regiment, came before Bavarian awards.

There was no specific order. Typically, one might be put in for the EK2, and the home state would respond by awarding its analogous basic award too. But because the award procedures were different, the state award might be awarded first. In other cases, the officer might be put in for the state award first, and the EK2 recommendation might come later. In some cases, not at all - you sometimes see medal bars with a state award and no EK2 (less likely for officers, but common soldiers in a state regiment might get only the state award). In yet other cases, an officer might get the EK2 and the state wouldn't respond. If he got his state's basic award, it might come later for an unrelated act of bravery or military merit. As for the EK1, assuming the officer got one at all, it might come before or after any state award. It could also come for a separate act or acts of valor, or might come for the same deed(s) as a state award. Paul gave you a Bavarian example. Here is an Oldenburger: Carl Becker OFAK2: 14.7.15 EK2: 23.7.15 OFAK1: 13.8.16 EK1: 17.6.17 HOH3X: 8.7.18 OV3bX: 23.8.18 And a Mecklenburg-Strelitzer: Kurt Kruse EK2: 22.10.14 MStK2: 30.6.15 EK1: 16.2.17 MStK1: 2.8.17 HOH3X: 2.10.18 And a few Saxons: Werner Freiherr von Beschwitz EK2: 16.10.14 SA3aX: 20.6.15 SH3: 3.8.16 SA3aXKr: 11.11.17 EK1: 24.12.17 Albert von Funcke EK2: 20.9.14 SA3aX: 10.12.14 EK1: 29.2.16 SA3aXKr: 25.5.16 SH3: 25.5.17 SV3aX: 12.11.17 SH2b: 9.9.18 Max Beyer: EK2: 27.1.15 EK1: 21.8.15 SV3aX: 2.10.15 Max Baumgärtel EK2: 30.12.14 SV3aX: 25.5.15 EK1: 19.7.15 SH3: 16.10.15 SA3X: 28.8.16 HOH3X: 29.11.16 Hans von Schönfels EK2: 24.10.14 EK1: 5.11.14 SA3aXKr: 10.12.14 SH3: 28.2.15 SV3aX: 4.8.16 SA3X: 8.12.16 SH2b: 15.11.17 KO2X: 29.10.18 Eugen Naumann EK2: 20.11.14 SA3aX: 20.2.15 EK1: 1.5.15 SH3: 21.7.15 SV3aX: 29.8.16 SA3X: 3.7.17 SH2b: 1.9.18 Hans von Mangoldt-Gaudlitz EK2: 16.9.14 SH3: 7.11.14 EK1: 12.1.15 SV3aX: 5.6.16 HOH3X: 1.10.16 SA3X: 21.2.18 KO2X: 31.10.18 Ernst Freiherr von dem Bussche-Haddenhausen EK2: 8.9.14 SH3: 24.11.14 EK1: 5.12.14 SA3aX: 6.11.15 SV3aX: 25.5.16 Georg Freiherr von dem Bussche-Haddenhausen EK2: 9.1.15 SV3aX: 19.3.15 EK1: 13.8.15 SH3: 11.11.17 SH2b: 17.4.18 PlM: 8.9.18

You could receive multiple awards as you moved up in rank, but - correct me if I'm wrong - you would only wear more than one if: 1. MVK as enlisted and later MVO as officer. 2. Peacetime award and wartime award (Art. XI of the Statutes: "Kriegs- und Friedensdekorationen werden nebeneinander, auch in verschiedenen Klassen, getragen;") 3. Awards with swords from separate wars (Verordnung d. bay. KM, 11.6.15: allowing that "... jene Militär-Verdienstorden und Militär-Verdienstkreuz mit Schwertern, welche vor August 1914 erworben wurden, neben den in diesem Kriege verliehenen Kriegsdekorationen des Militär-Verdienstordens weiter getragen werden dürfen.") The most MVOs I can remember seeing is on Franz Ritter von Epp. His were from separate conflicts: a 3rd Class with Crown and Swords from World War I (as well as a pinback Officer's Cross later in the war), a 3rd Class with Swords (Knight 1st Class) from the Herero War, and a Knight 2nd Class with Swords from China (no flames).

The vast majority of awards of the MVK 2. Klasse mit der Krone und Schwertern were to Offiziersstellvertreters. Also, besides Unterzahlmeisters, a number of awards to Oberfeuerwerkers, Ober-Musikmeisters, and at least a few to some other oddball ranks like Wallmeister. Also, I think most awards to Zahlmeister-Stellvertreters (Unterzahlmeisters), like other Beamtenstellvertreters, would be "am Bande für Kriegsverdienst". In the navy, awards to various petty officer ratings, including: Oberbootsmann, Obersteuermann, Oberstückmeister, Marine-Ingenieuroberaspirant, Obermaschinist, Funkentelegraphie-Obermeister, Obermeister, Obermaterialienverwalter, Torpedo-Obermaschinist, Obertorpeder, Oberfeuerwerker, Oberflugmeister, Flugobermechaniker, Bootsmann, Steuermann, Vermessungssteuermann, Marine-Ingenieuraspirant, Maschinist, Torpedo-Steuermann, Torpedo-Maschinist, Torpedo-Mechaniker. Also, in later years, there were a number of awards to Vizefeldwebels and Vizefeldwebels der Reserve. Presumably these were second awards to those who already had received the 2. Klasse mit Schwertern.

I don't know much about the medal, but it is for the WAD, not KhAD. At least that's the acronym on the bottom of the medal. KhAD, or "State Information Service" (Khedemat-e Ettala`at-e Dawlati), was the name of the Afghan KGB-equivalent until 1986 or so, when it became WAD, the Ministry for State Security (Wizaarat-e Amniyat-e Dawlati). So that would date the medal between 1986 and the fall of the Communist regime in 1992. Dave

Something is fishy about the names there. I agree that the name written there is Dallwitz, but there was no General von Dallwitz. According to the 1917 edition of the Gothaisches genealogisches Taschenbuch der uradeligen Häuser, the highest ranking member of the Adelsgeschlecht "von Dallwitz" in 1917 was a Major a.D., Johann Sigismund Günther von Dallwitz, born in 1864. There was a higher ranking civilian: Johann von Dallwitz, the Prussian Minister des Innern from 1910 to 1914 and Reichsstatthalter in Elsaß-Lothringen from 1914 to 1918, but I don't see how you get from a Reichsstatthalter in Strasbourg to a General in Silesia. "Dallwitz" also shows up in the names "Wegner von Dallwitz" (also "Dallwitz-Wegner") and (Reichs-) Freiherr von Canitz und Dallwitz, but no WW1 generals for these either. But furthermore, I can't find a "von Denne" in any of my sources for German or Austrian officers. Actually, I can't find a family "von Denne" anywhere. And there are lots of Brinckmans, Brinckmanns, and Brinkmanns, but no Brinkmans. Nor Volkamp. Volkamp, Brinkman and van Denne are Dutch names, though. So there's a possibility for some of them. But no "van Dallwitz"s. The only lieutenants Trenker I've come across are Austrians. Maybe someone added false names for some reason?

Communist Bulgaria 15 Years in the Armed Forces 10 Years in the Interior Ministry The last appears from the front to be the combat merit medal, but the ribbon is wrong. The ribbon is for the Medal "100th Anniversary of April Uprising 1876-1976". The reverse of the combat merit medal should have a star and the text "ЗА БОЕВА ЗАСЛУГА" ("For combatant merit").

RIR 98 started out the war as part of Festungsdivision Metz AKA Hauptreserve Metz, which became 33. Res.-Div. The regiment seems to have moved around a lot though. David Gregory has a page for an Oskar Körner who served in the regiment part of the war. He has RIR 98 as part of 9. Res.-Div. at least up to December 1915 and in 10. Res.-Div. in 1916.

Great to know. Thanks for the confirmation!

Karl von Flotow was promoted to Major on 8 November 1914. He was already a Major a.D. in the 1917 edition of Gothaisches genealogisches Taschenbuch der uradeligen Häuser. Since he was a native of Mecklenburg-Schwerin but did not receive the Militärverdienstkreuz by 1917 when he was a.D., I would guess he didn't have much wartime service (I only have MMVs through September 1917). Regards

Others wounded that day:

Just two awards: 15.5.17: EK2 15.12.17: Großh. bad. silb. Verdienst-Med. am Bande der Mil. Karl-Friedrich-Verd.-Med.

The colors are right, the lighting sucks. I have to get better pics. I have pinned it down with some degree of certainty to Dr. Max Schmidt, Stabsarzt u. Btl. Arzt, I./IR 71. His SEK3X came from Sondershausen on 5 June 1915. His peacetime EH3b dates from his service as an Oberarzt in the Sanitätsamt of the XI. Armeekorps. He was born in Berlin on 17 December 1874. After service as an Unterarzt in IR 82, he was promoted to Assistentarzt in August 1900 and transferred to III./IR 83. In January 1903 he was promoted to Oberarzt and transferred that May to XI. A.K. In 1904 he was assigned to FAR 11. Sometime shortly after that, he was ordered (kommandiert) to the University of Rostock and then to Jäger-Bataillon 14. In April 1907 he was promoted to Stabsarzt and in October 1907 assigned to the Kaiser Wilhelms-Akademie für das militärärztliche Bildungswesen. In 1910, he returned to FAR 11 as Abt. Arzt for the II. Abteilung. In 1912 he was transferred to IR 71. There is still the possibility that one of the other 670 recipients of the SEK3X from Schwarzburg-Sondershausen also had a peacetime EH3b and got nothing else but the EK and SEK3X, so I can't say with certainty. But your typical civilian recipient of the EH3b and nothing else would have been a citizen of one of the Saxon duchies, so you would expect he would have gotten swords to the EH3b or, if from Meiningen, the Cross for Merit in War. The process of elimination continues.

Here is about the only thing German I have added to my collection in the past three years. This is all I have for scans/photos right now. 1. 1914 Eisernes Kreuz II. Klasse 2. Fürstlich Schwarzburgisches Ehrenkreuz III. Klasse mit Schwertern 3. Herzoglich Sachsen-Ernestinischer Hausorden, Ritterkreuz II. Klasse Regards

I agree with Tim. Two Signums (Signa?) Laudis, probably one silver and one bronze. And #5 is the Laeso Militi, or Wound Medal. The photo studio imprint on the lower right indicates it was taken in Innsbruck. Innsbruck is the capitol of Tyrol.

I'm pretty sure such wounds have always been eligible. As the original War Department General Order stated, the Purple Heart was open to one with a "wound which necessitates treatment by a medical officer and which is received in action with an enemy..." They probably had a problem with people trying to claim Purple Hearts for wounds which were little more than scratches, so they began cracking down and focusing on how penetrative the wound was. This would have had unintended consequences for some with traumatic internal injuries, so they had to revisit the criteria to make sure deserving recipients weren't accidentally excluded. The Purple Heart wasn't created until 1932. When adopted, those eligible were those who had received a wound chevron or those who had been awarded a Meritorious Service Citation Certificate by the AEF. Those who received a Citation Certificate for heroism were eligible for the Silver Star, also created in 1932. As noted above, there was also a rule for eligibility for those who might not have had a wound chevron, but could document having been wounded. Sometime early in World War II, they changed the rules to eliminate the meritorious service awards (around the same time they created the Bronze Star?). It wasn't until 1943 that the Purple Heart was extended to the Department of the Navy as well (with retroactive elegibility). A story which may or may not be true is that the Purple Heart was originally only going to be for meritorious service, but the Army Chief of Staff, Gen. Douglas MacArthur, realized that while he would get a bunch of Silver Stars for his many citations for heroism while serving with the 42nd Division in World War I, he wouldn't get any Purple Hearts. So broadening the pool of eligibility to include those wounded or killed while doing their duty just happened to benefit him. I suppose this story would be appealing to critics of MacArthur who viewed him as a glory hound.

FAR 60 was part of the 17. Infanterie-Division for the entire war. A short history of the division can be found here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/17th_Division...erman_Empire%29 Infanterie-Regiment Hamburg (2. Hanseatisches) Nr. 76 was also part of the 17. ID. Since Hamburg had no artillery of its own, men of Hamburg who went into the artillery instead of the infantry probably went to FAR 60 or FAR 24.