Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Recommended Posts

    Posted

    Nice hats Nack!

    I have to be honest though, I'm not sure if the 1940 stamp is original, simply because it says 'Moscow'. Without a hint of who made it. No code number or factory name.

    I'm not commenting on the cap, just the stamp. Have you got Webster and Nelson's Red Army uniforms book? They have excellent photos of wartme stamps and earlier.

    But I love the OGPU visor!

    Thanks. As to the stamp, I know its a bit wierd, and I too have not seen another like it. I have the Webster/Nelson book as well as the Shalito book, but neither really sheds light on the stamp. I think the stamp says 1945 or 1948 to be honest. The hat is certainly old, from mid 40s to mid 50s for sure. I've noticed that dating this stuff is hard. Whatever the date, its a nice hat, which looks good with the uniform it is displayed with.

    • Replies 57
    • Created
    • Last Reply

    Top Posters In This Topic

    Posted

    I have sent off images of your (Nack) NKVD visor cap to Voronov, and, for further input, to a Russian language group that I check into from time to time, where there exists a few knowledgeable men... I have inquired with them concerning the round visor attribute and how it coincides with what I wrote previously about it existing on late 30s/early 40s caps.

    This subject (of visors) has always been one especially of interest to me. Date/mfg/depot/reissue stamps, & "museum" markings also. However, most of the time, the latter I have determined turn out to be merely a tool of the unscrupulous seller...

    As soon as I have replies, I will show them here accordingly.

    Nack, please, let us see the uniform you speak of that goes with your cap. I, and would assume the others, enjoy viewing what others have and discussing it.

    Posted (edited)

    Nack, please, let us see the uniform you speak of that goes with your cap. I, and would assume the others, enjoy viewing what others have and discussing it.

    Your wish is my command :) It is one of my favorites.

    And thanks again for sending the pics to the expert.

    Edited by Nack
    Posted

    My wish is that you box it up, less cap, orders, & medals if you want to keep at least some memento(s) of your former ownership of such a nice thing, and send it to me Global Express Mail with full insurance so I may have a comprehensive look-see...

    Whether or not I return it is another issue...

    Golly...

    Posted

    Nack that is a beautiful tunic!

    The 1943 Mundir is one of my favourites and an NKVD one... wow!

    If you don't wish to send it to Richie, I could look after it for you..

    Posted (edited)

    Thank you all for the nice comments, and generous offers to open space in my collection. I'll give it some thought, but it probably wont have much traction :D

    The hats seem to vary widely in price. NKVD items in general command a premium. I know a guy who has another blue NKVD frontier troops budyonovka if you want one :)

    Edited by Nack
    Posted

    Questions as to authenticity of the "1940s-dated" cap have come up, so I thought I'd post some more pictures to see what folks think. Here goes...

    Posted

    Questions as to authenticity of the "1940s-dated" cap have come up, so I thought I'd post some more pictures to see what folks think. Here goes...

    Posted (edited)

    And another. This is one of the rivits attaching one of the buttons.

    Edited by Nack
    Posted

    Here's the general shape. Looking for good news :unsure:

    It is certainly not a fake cap in my opinion Nack. Without even touching it, I can see it from here.

    Judging from my experiences, the sweatband is correct for late 40s/early 50s mfg. The chinstrap is not one of those flimsy, paper thin ones that are on the fakes, and the visor has nice age patina and crazing also.

    As Stewart wrote earlier, the only thing that does not seem right is the stamp. It could be a legit, but I think that more likely than not, it simply could have been added at one point in the past to increase the sale price by a few bucks.

    Us gullible Westerners just LOVE date stamps and markings. :P Really....

    Posted

    It is certainly not a fake cap in my opinion Nack. Without even touching it, I can see it from here.

    Judging from my experiences, the sweatband is correct for late 40s/early 50s mfg. The chinstrap is not one of those flimsy, paper thin ones that are on the fakes, and the visor has nice age patina and crazing also.

    As Stewart wrote earlier, the only thing that does not seem right is the stamp. It could be a legit, but I think that more likely than not, it simply could have been added at one point in the past to increase the sale price by a few bucks.

    Us gullible Westerners just LOVE date stamps and markings. :P Really....

    ...and BTW. The chinstrap buttons that are affixed with the prongs are a sign of late 40s/ 50s mfg also.

    Posted

    i think the 1948 stamp is ok; it fits the age of the hat and I have seen others. The more common problem is rubbing away part of the '8' and making it into a '0' to fool some collectors into paying double for a 1940 NKVD cap rather than a postwar 1948 MGB cap.

    Posted

    The more common problem is rubbing away part of the '8' and making it into a '0' to fool some collectors into paying double for a 1940 NKVD cap rather than a postwar 1948 MGB cap.

    Right on Daredevil... I remember in "the beginning" that this was a common thing. There were so may pieces with real date/mfg stamps that "mysteriously" had the last digit or two crudely erased. Even worse, more than once I have seen a hunk of fabric missing from that same spot. I have a few pieces that possess that notable feature.

    I'll dig them up and take a few images just for conversation's sake.

    It is a pity though that nowadays, there is such a flood of 100% "fuflo" things out there, and that people are gobbling them up simply because it has a stamp (which is just as fake as the item it resides in)...

    Posted

    As I stated at the beginning, I don't personally have authenticity iasues with the cap, as the seller is QUITE reputable :) But, as to the stamp--who knows? Really tho, who cares? If its actually from 1948, cool. If its 1954, still cool. Its still a nice piece that looks fab with with the tunic :beer: I'm just glad that no one thought it was totally fake.

    In any event, I think its been an interesting discussion, which illustrates to others that, as with other things, "God is in the details." Thanks for participating in the fun :)

    • 1 year later...
    Posted (edited)

    Nack,

    Somehow, I had previously missed this thread. Having a close and careful look at your NKVD cap, I must say that I am far from enthused with it. It has all the trademarks of local workshop production. Compare with the one RussiaMilitaria has just posted, the differences are glaring.

    Would this cap come from a "reputable dealer" located in NJ?

    Marc

    Edited by Lapa
    Posted

    Nack,

    Somehow, I had previously missed this thread. Having a close and careful look at your NKVD cap, I must say that I am far from enthused with it. It has all the trademarks of local workshop production. Compare with the one RussiaMilitaria has just posted, the differences are glaring.

    Would this cap come from a "reputable dealer" located in NJ?

    Marc

    Marc -- the cap indeed traveled from NJ, not Tenafly NJ though. There is very convincing wear both to the visor and sweatband. Are you of the opinion it was artificially aged?

    ~Nack

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.