lambert Posted February 5, 2013 Posted February 5, 2013 Concordo com você Jim Jim I agree with you.The price she can reach the end of the auction, can be very good for the seller. is a piece of fantasy, interesting but of lower value.no wonder if they achieve a high price unfortunately .. atenciosamente Lambert
ThaiDave Posted March 1, 2013 Posted March 1, 2013 Clasps from the top down numbered 1, 2 & 4 are not official issue. They are late reproductions sold by vendors at shows and veterans conventions. You can find them on ebay each and every day, mostly as single army clasp for sale. see these: http://www.ebay.com/itm/AISNE-BAR-WW-I-Victory-Medal-DEVICE-/290855069233?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item43b8502631 http://www.ebay.com/itm/A01-ARMY-WWI-VICTORY-MEDAL-CAMBRAI-BAR-/271101521558?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3f1ee8ee96 http://www.ebay.com/itm/A09-ARMY-WWI-VICTORY-MEDAL-OISE-AISNE-BAR-/271124300245?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3f204481d5 http://www.ebay.com/itm/LYS-BAR-WW-I-Victory-Medal-DEVICE-/390531881004?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item5aed83982c This seller of #2 and #3 is gshank0121 the same as mcstls (aka Mike Shank from Virginia)
ThaiDave Posted March 13, 2013 Posted March 13, 2013 A new type Thai fake here : http://gmic.co.uk/index.php/topic/49862-thaisiamese-victory-medals/page-2#entry537603
RobW Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 A new type Thai fake here : http://gmic.co.uk/index.php/topic/49862-thaisiamese-victory-medals/page-2#entry537603 Hello Dave, I would suggest this item is not a fake but moreso a contemporary to the 1930's French reproduction. Regards, Rob
ThaiDave Posted April 15, 2013 Posted April 15, 2013 Some more mtlcls fakes on ebay: Greek Victory Medal. This is a very nice medal with very good detail. I have no idea how old it is. It has a nice mark on it at about 7:00 and looks good. This is a very nice medal with very good detail. It is marked on the front. I have no idea of its age. It is hard to find one of these in this good of shape. US WWI Victory Medal, France Bar and Maltese Cross. This is a very nice Victory Medal. It has a French style top bar, France Bar and a Maltese Cross on it. It has Fraser on the bottom face of the medal at about the 5:00 position. Victory Medal This is a very nice medal with very good detail. It has a mark on the back. I got it at a show and I do not know the age of it. This is a very nice one with very good markings. It has the writing on the front at the bottom and the mark on the back. It is hard to find one of these with all the markings. I do not know the age of it.
ThaiDave Posted April 15, 2013 Posted April 15, 2013 (edited) Some fake bars Unofficial Army Battle Clasp Very nice set of 17 Unofficial Bars. They are the harder ones to find. All but one has FRANCE stamped on the back. The one that does not is Offensive Sector. You get what is pictured. They are very nice for any collection. Here is a very nice, mounted, ready to put in a shadow box set. You will get what is pictured. Complete matched set, 14 US Army Battle Clasp Set. Bronze clasps with the names of the thirteen campaigns and one titled "Defensive Sector", Collar Disk and Star. etc Edited April 15, 2013 by ThaiDave
lambert Posted June 26, 2013 Posted June 26, 2013 Some photos of Polish Victory Medal (Fantasia created a few years) to deceive collectors eager for a new example of Vic.However, even if false, is a beautiful specimen .. Lambert
Bilco Posted June 27, 2013 Posted June 27, 2013 Hi Lambert, A nice example - I hope you didn't pay too much for it! I see our old friend mcstls has three on eBay at the moment - one of each type - at a starting price of $78. There seem to be at least 3 suspension types and 3 reverses, so potentially 9 variants ... Bill
johnnymac Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 Good morning, Bill and Lambert, I have found there are more than three there are four suspensions, three reverses, with just one obverse, all with the same inspector mark and manufacturer stamp, Humm......... Regards, Jim
lambert Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 (edited) Good morning Jim.. Now we have version "unofficial" of this fantasy? .........very creative. unfortunately some people still believe this. Lambert Edited June 28, 2013 by lambert
lambert Posted June 28, 2013 Posted June 28, 2013 Hi Lambert, A nice example - I hope you didn't pay too much for it! I see our old friend mcstls has three on eBay at the moment - one of each type - at a starting price of $78. There seem to be at least 3 suspension types and 3 reverses, so potentially 9 variants ... Bill Hi Bill not even. lambert
lambert Posted July 13, 2013 Posted July 13, 2013 Known copies of Vic Cuban, a photo larger. In my opinion a copy ugliest I've ever seen. .. of course .. this all wrong.. Lambert
lambert Posted July 22, 2013 Posted July 22, 2013 Attention. Vic Romanian sale on Ebay. Fake 271243685082 Lambert
lambert Posted July 22, 2013 Posted July 22, 2013 Vic Italian for sale. Fake Item number: 271243685081 lambert
johnnymac Posted July 22, 2013 Posted July 22, 2013 I do not understand why? there is a fake Italian for $40-60 when you can purchase an original for the same price!
RobW Posted July 23, 2013 Posted July 23, 2013 (edited) I do not understand why? there is a fake Italian for $40-60 when you can purchase an original for the same price! Hello Jim, Probably because not all collectors do due diligence before obtaining an item. This can be due to being new to the collecting area or not necessarily having access to a good source of credible information. Both volumes by the late Mr Laslo are good starting points but not all collectors either have a copy or access to them. A quick search of online resources, of which this forum is but one, would be able to give a prospective purchaser both the information, context, and pictures, to make an informed decision. This doesn't always happen. Unfortunately as long as there is a source of new customers such fakes will always be sold. Regards, Rob Edited July 23, 2013 by RobW
johnnymac Posted July 26, 2013 Posted July 26, 2013 Rob, I was talking about those who have these medals made, I would think the total overhead cost with be so sizeable that it might not be worth it in the long run in cost, effect, and time. Nevertheless, these medals seem to keep showing up! Regards, as well Jim,
RobW Posted July 28, 2013 Posted July 28, 2013 Rob, I was talking about those who have these medals made, I would think the total overhead cost with be so sizeable that it might not be worth it in the long run in cost, effect, and time. Nevertheless, these medals seem to keep showing up! Regards, as well Jim, Hello Jim, I suppose as long as they have spent the money on the initial outlay of dies etc... they would have to attempt to reoup the money in the end. As you have indicated these medals do indeed keep appearing on the online auction sites. I would also suggest they are probably being sold at the militaria shows in the US as well. Regards, Rob
johnnymac Posted July 28, 2013 Posted July 28, 2013 Rob, I am not as optimistic that these medals are selling as aggressively as you are. Fakes are common as you mentioned on the online auctions and are maybe the main source to reach the buying public. However I follow many repro medals and notice many are passed over to only be relisted by the seller. Best wishes, Jim
Bilco Posted August 3, 2013 Posted August 3, 2013 (edited) Hi Gents, A seller in the UK is offering 'die-stamped copies' of various vics: Brazil - item # 111130907437 Cuba - item # 111134543740 South Africa - item # /121153624876 Romania - item # 111134542760 Portugal - item # /121153624876 French Pautot-Mattei - item # 111130907438 French Chobillom - item # 111134542930 Siam - item # 121151669390 Great Britain - item # 111134541121 Czech - item # 111134543527 Japan - item # 121153624690 Colour and detail should be a give-away should any unscrupulous seller-on buy them ... Bill Edited August 3, 2013 by Bilco
RobW Posted August 4, 2013 Posted August 4, 2013 Hi Gents, A seller in the UK is offering 'die-stamped copies' of various vics: Colour and detail should be a give-away should any unscrupulous seller-on buy them ... Bill Hello Bill, At least in both the title and details of each of these listings, the items are clearly marked as being a die stamped COPY. So these are clearly not being advertised or listed as the genuine item. I would agree that both the colour and finish are easy to spot as not contemporary or original, but in this case there appears no intent to deceive. On the other hand there is another vendor, clearly listed on earlier posts in this topic (with pictures), that lists their items with an ambiguous title and detail. The larger issue here is one of intent to deceive. Good quality die-stamped copies listed as such are one thing. Items listed with the intention to decive the collector into believing they are original is another matter entirely. Where there is sufficient money to be made in selling items of dubious provenance someone will always make such a commercial product. It pays to be wary. Regards, Rob
Bilco Posted August 4, 2013 Posted August 4, 2013 Hi Rob, I agree with everything you say - my thinking was that someone could buy them as copies, then age them and try to pass them off as genuine. The other thing that occurs to me is the cost of these copies - between £9 and £13 - which links to the conversation you have been having with Jim - how much does it cost to produce die-struck copies like these, and can they be sold at these prices and make a profit? Bill
ThaiDave Posted August 4, 2013 Posted August 4, 2013 The Siam examples from this maker I have seen have very rough detail, compared to a genuine example. However, it is a shame that they are not marked COPY. Even when a seller describes such medals as copies, invariably the next seller of such medals may not be so careful in their identification... Reasonable diligence would lead to them to be permanently marked.
lambert Posted August 5, 2013 Posted August 5, 2013 Item selling fake .. the seller has not indicated that this item is copy. among other items "rare"ID 151095344470 Lambert
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now