For part 1) Good fakes DO look genuine. With these stars looking 100% genuine is not enough to win a prize part 2) If you want them for yourself and you got them out of the woodwork, good for you. A regular buyer would ask what the NSDAP stamp is doing on there, question a bit the quality of the badge and why they look to be made by the same person on the same cloth, but have 2 different languages and the one has a bogus stamp and the other not? Sometimes when it comes to "iffy" objects, it is a question of belief. I would see these at a show and think "Yeah right....." and move on. If you are happy with them, fine, but as you posted them I assume some opinions and chit chat are what is called for. Best Chris