Post WW I bavarian bar

[scottplen]

Here one i like But gun shy!!! Does it look good??? Its super clean looking very fresh! thats my worry!!

[scottplen]

back

[HeikoGrusdat]

ribbon N°4 is wrong for the Flanderncross , or the cross wrong for the ribbon....

Yes it looks superclean......and I think the bavarian MVO is a too high class for the rest , but that must say others....

[Ulsterman]

Hmmmmmmmm....odd that a Bavarian wouldn't have a Jubilee but would have a centenl. medal-...maybe Navy...but still, looks like it was made Friday. Not for me.

[Claudius]

and I don't like the thread color used to tie down the Centennial, Flanderncross or Hindenburg....

[Claudio]

Well, well,... I don't know if this bar should be discussed; it's quite a waste of time.

First of all the combination presents a couple of questions already:

- Why a Zentenarmedaille with a BMVO? Possible, but than this officer would have been a Prussian... but no medals from Prussia? Not even a long service medal (also as reservist)

- If this officer was Bavarian why there isn't the Luitpold jubilee medal (1905-08) or any other LS or commemortive medals?

- With the Hindeburg Cross (FEK) issued around 34-35, this bar should have put together after 35? Why is this guy wearing the Flanderncross (like Heiko said with the wrong ribbon), since all veteran and fantasy medals issued during the Weimar era is still in place?

- Construction: looks brand-new, but the medals show diffent shades of wearing conditions? Strange... also I don't like the colour of the threads and the material and pieces being used (needle, backing, color of the thread). It doesn't screem to me like being typically constructed before WWII

Finally I can say that I wouldn't touch it even with a 10 meters long pole... but this is just my guts' feeling! ;-)

Ciao,

Claudio

[scottplen]

guess i am passing ! Will i ever find a real bar????

i am going to keep searching hope you guys don't mind looking at bars for me?

[saschaw]

The combination is not impossible, e.g. for a (Non-Bavarian) Navy officer, still I do not like this bar.

[scottplen]

someone bought it its off the site! It was way expensive!!!! for a ???? bar