Guy

Identification of a medal ribbon.

19 posts in this topic

Identification of a medal ribbon.

Does anyone know what the medal ribbon with the black 1 means ?

Thanks

 

 

_DSC0307a_01.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thailand - Order of the White Elephant.  Not sure of the class.  My book shows metal devices to show class.  Probably Officer or Commander.

Who's the recipient? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks my friends for the identification.:thumbup:

The recipient :  Du Four J.C.H.M

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gosh, had to look very closely for the "black one"! (lol!)

And what is the ribbon just above the "black one", please.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's the Commemorative Cross of the House of King Albert  [Croix Commémorative de la Maison du Roi Albert -Herinneringskruis van het Huis van Koning Albert], established in May, 1934 and awarded to those close to the royal household, supposedly only during that month.  A relatively rare award; copies exist.  The centers are separately affixed and sometimes missing.   Image below  [there’s a veterans’ organization with a quite similar badge].   

th.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Stuka f said:

Gosh, had to look very closely for the "black one"! (lol!)

And what is the ribbon just above the "black one", please.

Hello Kris,

Thats the "Cross of the Black Spot"

@922F

He was :

Officier attaché à la maison de Roi et attaché hononaire au Cabinet de Roi.

This is also one of the many officers that I have to check their files in the Royal Army Museum in Brussels.
But for lack of time I do not succeed yet :(
That's something I have to do when I retire:whistle:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guy's! :-)

Indeed a rare medal; never saw one so far.

11 hours ago, Guy said:

I have to check their files in the Royal Army Museum in Brussels.
But for lack of time I do not succeed yet :(
That's something I have to do when I retire:whistle:

Are you retiring soon?

Because it seems the Museum is going to close down and the collection will be spread over other existing museum's...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ID: 9   Posted (edited)

 

On ‎1‎/‎02‎/‎2017 at 07:24, 922F said:

It's the Commemorative Cross of the House of King Albert  [Croix Commémorative de la Maison du Roi Albert -Herinneringskruis van het Huis van Koning Albert], established in May, 1934 and awarded to those close to the royal household, supposedly only during that month.  A relatively rare award; copies exist.  The centers are separately affixed and sometimes missing.   Image below  [there’s a veterans’ organization with a quite similar badge].   

th.jpg

922F,

What is the difference between the two medals.

What is the difference between the fake/copy  and the real one ?

Edited by Guy
wrong text

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Guy said:

What is the difference between the two medals.

Picture 1 is the front of the medal and the "A" is the revers. (If this is what you mean).

I'm very interested in the difference between a copy and a real one (and if possible, the documentation or source of it) since I have the medal in my collection. (see pics)


th_039642593_IMG_1945_122_411lo.JPG

th_039646985_IMG_1946_122_359lo.JPG

th_039650662_IMG_1947_122_424lo.JPG

 

Vincent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to Borné this medal was created by King Leopold III by Decree on 10 may 1934, aiming to award those who served  Albert I, who died on 17 january 1934.

It was awarded to those who served in the royal households of Albert I and/or queen Elisabeth (1909-1934) and/or the households when they were the Count and Countess of Flanders (1905-1909).

So it might be possible that they were all awarded during the month may of 1934, since no one could qualify after that date. Unfortunately Borné does not mention it.

 

Vincent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

922F,

Thanks for that answer.

I mean the difference between de real an a copy /fake medal ?

That difference, I would like to know.

I have also the Borné in my libary

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Offhand, I recall detailed description of the award & instituting decree most particuliarly in Quinot, 5th edition.  I bet that other general works on Belgian awards will have information as well.  

These awards were best discussed at a public event, in my experience, at a MEDEC meeting in Antwerp in mid-1994.  Samples of genuine pieces, cased and uncased, were displayed alongside fakes.  Can't remember which firm made them, de Greef or Fonson.  Do not remember an awarding document displayed at the meeting [or if one existed].  Think it could not be awarded posthumously.  I certainly do recall that the the award always had to be worn full-size or miniature from the ribbon and that service ribbons were not supposed to be worn with out the 'bijou'.  I seem to remember that Willy D. or Eric T. had a copy of the 10 May decree.   Eric T. had some information regarding it at one of the Army Museum shows about that time as well.  Maybe someone wrote an article in the MEDEC journal concerning around 1994-5??  My memory is weak!!

I believe that Eric T. is a GMIC member perhaps he will see this and clarify.

 

Overall, fakes look somewhat like copy 100th Anniversary Ostend-Dover Ferry Line or Telegrapf commemoration decorations in workmanship--not as crisp detail or finishing as originals.  Fakes possibly made using the veteran's society badge corpus but with replaced centers and the "A" in the angle of the arms either not pierced or not apparently separately attached.  The enamel is flat on the arms not slightly domed.  Seem to recall that the centers looked more like thin castings rather than stampings.  It was possible in the mid-'90's to get ribbon from De Greef.

Somewhere, maybe in the Dynasty Museum, there's supposedly a roll of people awarded this decoration but I never saw it.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My notes say that it was awarded to all living members of the Royal Household on 10 May 1934.

Still looking for a good picture of the beast for my website...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, 922F said:

Fakes possibly made using the veteran's society badge corpus but with replaced centers and the "A" in the angle of the arms either not pierced or not apparently separately attached.

Is this the veteran's medal that you mean? If they did use this it should be easy to recognize. According to an article by Borné it was created by the National Union of Military Veterans of Leopold II (wich was founded in 1947).

th_115699556_IMG_1948_122_540lo.JPG

th_115704409_IMG_1949_122_550lo.JPG

th_115709873_IMG_1950_122_78lo.JPG

th_115714856_IMG_1951_122_507lo.JPG 
     

Vincent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, same one.  However, the fakers, besides replacing the ribbon and centers, must have used a varient veterans' badge type as their begining point as copy crosses were enameled on the reverse. These copies did not have any legend struck into them as the veterans' badges do.  I remember a copy with non-pierced monogram that looked like the monogram was struck when the cross was struck, similar, in that respect, to your example on the far left.   I had not seen the type of veterans' badge without monogram in the arms before.  

 

Possibly, and maybe easier, copies may have started with a Military Cross (Croix Militaire/Militaire Kruis] corpus.  This would make the enamel work easier, would not have problem of removing die-struck legend, and fake monogram could disguise removal of the swords.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@922F

You spoke about seeing cased ones in 1994. Do you, by any chance, remember the box it was in. Mine came in a red one with a crown on it (J. Fonson) and I presume this is not the original box but one for the Order of the Crown. But since I haven't seen a cased example of this medal I can't be certain.

 

Vincent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry, do not remember.  However, I had/have a cased example and am now in the process of unpacking nearly 60 years worth of collection [and have done for past 3 years, so no promise when or what I find] and when/if it turns up will certainly post bijou and case here.  Don't recall but mine may have a missing reverse center.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

60 years ... that must be a hell of a collection you got. I hope you can find the medal and many other "hidden" or "lost" teasures :). Don't feel shy to share the rare or uncommon ones with us :P.

 

Vincent

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now