Komtur

The difference to the here dicussed Crown Orders is, that these are mostly very scarce items (as Trevor wrote e.g. 1st classes with Red Eagle Order ribbon between the arms or with swords or swords on the ring or both!). There was no or only a hand full of recepients still living after 1918. Therefore in this case we see a significant disproportion of circulating items on today marked and the need of privately by wearers bought orders. They overflowed the collector marked always offered as originals in the 1970ies via one auction house and one dealer. Besides this they are marked W for Wagner, but have a significant different design (as Trevor desribed) to awarded Crown Orders. In my opinion because of these reasons the only clear description can be: FAKE. Regards, Komtur.

Dr. Edmund Huth

The Prussian orders were awarded only to officers or to similar ranking civil persons. The Allgemeine Ehrenzeichen (General Honour Decoration) were instituted for lower military or civil ranks. To have a possibility for more differentiation in honoring persons of the lower social classes the Allgemeine Ehrenzeichen in Gold (General Honour Decoration in Gold) were created in 1890. Because of economical reasons these massive golden medals were replaced in 1900 by the Kreuz des Allgemeinen Ehrenzeichen (Cross of General Honour Decoartion). In 1912 the decorations ranking below the orders were supplemented by the Verdienstkreuz in Gold (Honour Cross in Gold), Verdienstkreuz in Silber (Honour Cross in Silver) and Allgemeines Ehrenzeichen in Bronze (General Honour Decoration in Bronze). At the end of the monarchy there were the following non order lower decorations (from highest to lowest): 1. Verdienstkreuz in Gold 2. Verdienstkreuz in Silber 3. Kreuz des Allgemeinen Ehrenzeichens (former medal Allgemeines Ehrenzeichen in Gold) 4. Allgemeines Ehrenzeichen in Silber 5. Allgemeines Ehrenzeichen in Bronze To make it more complicated there was the possibility to award the three crosses (1.-3.) with the Royal Crown or to award the Royal Crown to these crosses. That is roughly the developement of the decoration system below the orders after 1839. In the early 19th century there were some other regulations and changes. Regards, Komtur.

Both decorations were not awarded to officers or similar civil ranks. Regards, Komtur.

I think that´s the case. Possibly the ribbon in the buttonhole, worn daily, is sewed with the uniform and therefore can no be removed easily, if one decided to wear the whole orderbar. Regards, Komtur.

Indeed. The different ribbons for the Prussian Orders (Red Eagle Order, Crown Order, House Order of Hohenzollern) were defined in 1864 on the occasian of the war with Denmark. The black ribbon with white stripes, also known as Combattant Ribbon, can be traced back to the Iron Cross ribbon from 1813 and goes primarily with the sword decorations of the three orders above. This regulation was only for natives, foreigners received sword decorations on the statute ribbon, what we can see especially for Austrians, Turks and Bulgarians in WW1. Because of the creation of sword decorations in 1848, some years before the ribbon regulations in 1864, we find awards "mit Schwertern" of the Red Eagle Order on the statute (white ribbon with red stripes) before 1864 also for Prussian natives. These persons were allowed in 1864, to change their ribbons to the black and white combattant version. More complicated are the regulations for the white ribbon with black stripes, also created in 1864 for the main three Prussian Orders. The tradition of this kind of ribbon goes also back to the 1813 Iron Cross, in this case of its noncombattant ribbon. It is related to services in the context of wars, but for not directly fighting persons. Therefore we find this ribbon mostly awarded to military officials ("Militärbeamte"). If these persons were in direct contact to the fight or front ("im feindlichen Feuer"), they received decorations with swords on the white/black ribbon, if they were not, without swords on the white/black ribbon. Decorations on non statuary ribbons are rare. In the period form 1848 to1918 were about 112.000 awards of the Red Eagle Order 4th class. In the same period we find about 3.200 awards of this class of the Red Eagle Order with swords and (from 1864 on) with the black/white ribbon. More scarce are awards with the white/black ribbon - in the same space of time there were about 560, half with and half without swords. Higher classes of the Red Eagle Order with the white/black ribbon are rarities with low single- or double-figure award numbers. These numbers are similarly for the Prussian Crown Order. Some exceptions are mentioned by Dave. Regards, Komtur.

Possibly EK2 1914, Austria Marianenkreuz, Landwehrdienstauszeichnung 2. Klasse, Austria Ehrenzeichen vom Roten Kreuz 2. Klasse. Regards, Komtur.

This group was discussed here before, but I could not find the thread. As I remember there were some doubts about it. Could this person please be checked by the new source Glenn found, the KuK 1918 Jahrbuch für Militärärzte? Thanks, Komtur.

Oh dear

Unfortunately I am not the jury - but I am quite sure you catched him . To many hints give me this good feeling. Great job! Thanks and regards, Komtur. BTW: The center of the BMV4XKr seems to be made of gold. "J.L." and "950" and the enamel on the lower arm is cracked (as always).

In some way it is consoling, that you NOT got him in minutes Should rename my threads to Non-Identifiable-To-Be-Medal Bars Regards, Komtur.

OK then. Next try. Sorry, the easier ones are solved before, so only the tricky ones are left But here may be a chance: the combination and the backing smells like navy. Sold from a dealer as "from private source" and "a doctor from Hamburg". I couldn´t find him in the 1918 rank list. Thanks and regards, Komtur.

Thanks for that input. Unfortunately I have no idea how to confirm him via other sources. His career and positions in WW1 would be of interest ... Regards, Komtur.

Just by chance I noticed, that the Godet tag with "Königl. Hofjuweliere" not fits with the 1934 cross. But this could be a late addition without changing the old tag. On the button and the ribbon bar the Red Cross Medal is missing, so it must be the second to last award. I have this bar in my collection for some years and Daniel may forgive me asking now on this place again and always the same question: WHO COULD THIS BE? Thanks and regards, Komtur.

this bar and again and again to the master of research gnomes. Regards, Komtur.

A late (1917/18) silver gilt Crown Order 3rd class with X, but not much more to cross check Nonetheless thanks for trying! Regards, Komtur.

This was indeed a fine teamwork research Congrats Claudio to this immaculate Godet now with a name! Regards, Komtur.

I believe, because of the gold center. Regards, Komtur.

Did you check the REO4 in the Kgl. Pr. Ordenslisten? Regards, Komtur.

Groß-Berlin must fold too. Tried double check Crown Order with Johanniter from the Ordensliste, but to many von, Freiherr, Graf etc. among them. I have no other idea ... Regards, Komtur.

I know, it is thin ice, but I think, Hofmeier is very suspect to be the person, we are searching for. His medal bar on the painting seems to be the same combination AND his documents were sold too. Thanks! Komtur. PS: I added another picture of him, before Red Eagle Order promotion to the 2nd class.

For the first glance no chance ... - BUT - Prussian 25 years service cross WITHOUT any Prussian order as it is always suspect for a general or an admiral rank. The owner made in 1901 a trip to China, so it must come down to a few persons of these ranks. No reactivation in 1914. Blue backing! No non-Prussian awards on the bar ... - THEREFORE - any chance Best Regards, Komtur.

May be. But also some other connections because of Willis sister Sophie are possible. I am quite sure, that therefore a few Greeks with a Crown Order 3rd class can be found in the Ordenslisten. Because of this I did not look there until now. Regards, Komtur.

Another extraordinary cute one for you folks: