Bundesrepublik Did you buy my 7 place medal bar on black pillow?

[kevin1261]

http://gmic.co.uk/uploads/monthly_03_2009/post-4024-1238311680.jpghttp://gmic.co.uk/uploads/monthly_03_2009/post-4024-1238311529.jpgIf you bought my 7 place medal bar,years ago I have the chain that goes with and would like to see if you want to keep this set together....

If one of the mods needs to move to the selling please go ahead.

Edited March 29, 2009 by kevin1261

[Kev in Deva]

Hallo Kevin,

nice sentiment in trying to relocate items, that have been seperated,

But as with any item that is for sale and as per forum rules

you are required to state a price, postage rates and method of payment,

as well as putting the item in the Sales Section.

Kevin in Deva, :beer:

Edited March 29, 2009 by Kev in Deva

[kevin1261]

Wouldnt let me post in sales.............delete this and and I 'll try another way.

Hallo Kevin,

nice sentiment in trying to relocate items, that have been seperated,

But as with any item that is for sale and as per forum rules

you are required to state a price, postage rates and method of payment,

as well as putting the item in the Sales Section.

Kevin in Deva,

[Chris Boonzaier]

I think it is OK to have this here, main thing is to find the buyer. Sometimes selling is not the main reason for a post and from what I see, he is not offering yet, first seeing if the buyer of the bar wants it.

What would be the point of putting it on the for sale stand with a price if it is for now not for sale to all comers.

Best

Chris

[Guest Rick Research]

Right. This is reunification for a specific person of a split group and a VERY nice gesture indeed. I hope the pair can be gotten back together again. Miracles DO happen online. :cheers:

[Paul R]

Right. This is reunification for a specific person of a split group and a VERY nice gesture indeed. I hope the pair can be gotten back together again. Miracles DO happen online.

Just a comment on the bar alone... I have never seen four long service medals mounted at the same time. I hope that you are able to reunite the chain with the bar!

[kevin1261]

Cool thanks,it really is offered to one person.....and if not I'll keep it.

Just a comment on the bar alone... I have never seen four long service medals mounted at the same time. I hope that you are able to reunite the chain with the bar!

[General2]

Hi. Just looking at the medal bar.....the EK and KVK are on the wrong ribbons.....and i also have never seem 4 long service awards mounted like this...why or how would a WW2 soldier have the 25 Year long service cross? When these were awarded in 1957 did service count right up to 1957 or to the end of the war in 1945??

Thanks

John

[kevin1261]

Thats what I really lke about the bar,was the wrong awards on the wrong ribbons.I thought somewhere I read that during the war years,the time was doubled.(Icould be full of crap

Hi. Just looking at the medal bar.....the EK and KVK are on the wrong ribbons.....and i also have never seem 4 long service awards mounted like this...why or how would a WW2 soldier have the 25 Year long service cross? When these were awarded in 1957 did service count right up to 1957 or to the end of the war in 1945??

Thanks

John

Edited March 30, 2009 by kevin1261

[Kev in Deva]

Thats what I really lke about the bar,was the wrong awards on the wrong ribbons.

So the chances are its a post war put together :speechless1:

[kevin1261]

Ya never know, thats why Imthinking of giving it up....

So the chances are its a post war put together

[Kev in Deva]

Ya never know, thats why Imthinking of giving it up....

Kevin1261, confusing, I thought you said the large bar was sold a number of years ago?

if its (the large bar) in that configuration then the possibility is the mini chain items are not related to the large bar.

Kevin in Deva. :unsure:

[kevin1261]

Well lets see,I sold this bar in 03 maybe 04,when I sold alot of my collection and my M1A supermatch to buy a 2003 harley,So if I bought the bar and tthe chain at the same time,same auction,how are they not related?

Kevin1261, confusing, I thought you said the large bar was sold a number of years ago?

if its (the large bar) in that configuration then the possibility is the mini chain items are not related to the large bar.

Kevin in Deva.

Edited March 30, 2009 by kevin1261

[Kev in Deva]

Well lets see,I sold this bar in 03 maybe 04,when I sold alot of my collection and my M1A supermatch to buy a 2003 harley,So if I bought the bar and tthe chain at the same time,same auction,how are they not related?

Hallo Kev,

I am not implying you put the items together, but, if the large item is a post WW2 put together,

which possibly means assembled for the purpose of selling,

why would the wrong ribbons and medal combo feature in the order of the layout?

The combination of the two items a s a set raises more questions than answers.

I cannot imagine how the owner would have had an incorrectly assembled large size bar

from the period of WW2 and a correct mini bar alongside.

I presume there was no Provenance or paperwork naming the original recipient?

Kevin in Deva.

[kevin1261]

These are 57 items,I also have a nother medal (the red cross bar posted else were here) so if the ribbons dont match the awards....I also have a real nice bar with a 57WW1 on a WW2 ribbon,so when I try to marry that up to its match,which were minis,you gonna have a HARD ON for that on also?And how many items do you have names for? this way I gave up collecting in the first place.In fact delete this whole topic,Ive had enough.

Hallo Kev,

I am not implying you put the items together, but, if the large item is a post WW2 put together,

which possibly means assembled for the purpose of selling,

why would the wrong ribbons and medal combo feature in the order of the layout?

The combination of the two items a s a set raises more questions than answers.

I cannot imagine how the owner would have had an incorrectly assembled large size bar

from the period of WW2 and a correct mini bar alongside.

I presume there was no Provenance or paperwork naming the original recipient?

Kevin in Deva.

[Kev in Deva]

These are 57 items,I also have a nother medal (the red cross bar posted else were here) so if the ribbons dont match the awards....I also have a real nice bar with a 57WW1 on a WW2 ribbon,so when I try to marry that up to its match,which were minis,you gonna have a HARD ON for that on also?And how many items do you have names for? this way I gave up collecting in the first place.In fact delete this whole topic,Ive had enough.

The whole purpose of this Forum is to promote discussion with regards the objects in our hobby

in a Gentlemanly manner if you have an attitude problem when questions are asked with regards the items

you post that's your concern, but, seemingly getting a straight answer in comprehensible English

is a problem for you, (perhaps English is not your first language. )

But, my understanding is, that a set of items, are items that come from an original owner

and to be able to claim that, there is normally some type of Provenance available.

Because the items were sold to you that way does not necessarily mean they were originally that way.

I find it odd that the large medal bar, even if a 57er, should have such a basic mistake

as the K.V.K. first and the Iron Cross second,

the original owner certainly would have known the items were assembled in the wrong sequence,

and had the mistake corrected, in this day and age to many items are turning up, that are very modern fabrication

and people interested in these items from a collecting point of view have to have the right to ask questions, so as to learn

if the item is an original period manufactire or a modern fabrication.

Kevin in Deva. :beer:

[kevin1261]

Wow, I dont know what picture your looking at,the ribbons are wrong,the chain came with the bar,SOOO all i was wanting was to se if the gentlemen that bought the bar would like the rest of it the way I bought....O.K.? simple and easy,like most people that buy militaria,no i did not buy from the orignal owner,I didnt buy any of my collection from orignal owners.....so your telling me if its not from original owners its not good?....Is this how you get your items,by telling people there no good,and buying for a few bucks?You are the only one with a problem with what I'm trying to do.So my is that?..I cleared out my info so....If the guy that wants to get back he wont have a chance.And as far as english being my only language...well I have a few english words for you in Gentlemanly fashion,but please go back and lookat the rest of my collection I posted before and tell me how much junk I have,Like I said this why I quit collecting and will not try to get the 2 remaining sets together.......

The whole purpose of this Forum is to promote discussion with regards the objects in our hobby

in a Gentlemanly manner if you have an attitude problem when questions are asked with regards the items

you post that's your concern, but, seemingly getting a straight answer in comprehensible English

is a problem for you, (perhaps English is not your first language. )

But, my understanding is, that a set of items, are items that come from an original owner

and to be able to claim that, there is normally some type of Provenance available.

Because the items were sold to you that way does not necessarily mean they were originally that way.

I find it odd that the large medal bar, even if a 57er, should have such a basic mistake

as the K.V.K. first and the Iron Cross second,

the original owner certainly would have known the items were assembled in the wrong sequence,

and had the mistake corrected, in this day and age to many items are turning up, that are very modern fabrication

and people interested in these items from a collecting point of view have to have the right to ask questions, so as to learn

if the item is an original period manufactire or a modern fabrication.

Kevin in Deva.

Edited March 30, 2009 by kevin1261

[Kev in Deva]

Wow, I dont know what picture your looking at,the ribbons are wrong,the chain came with the bar,SOOO all i was wanting was to se if the gentlemen that bought the bar would like the rest of it the way I bought....O.K.? simple and easy,like most people that buy militaria,no i did not buy from the orignal owner,I didnt buy any of my collection from orignal owners.....so your telling me if its not from original owners its not good?....Is this how you get your items,by telling people there no good,and buying for a few bucks?You are the only one with a problem with what I'm trying to do.So my is that?..I cleared out my info so....If the guy that wants to get back he wont have a chance.And as far as english being my only language...well I have a few english words for you in Gentlemanly fashion,but please go back and lookat the rest of my collection I posted before and tell me how much junk I have,Like I said this why I quit collecting and will not try to get the 2 remaining sets together.......

You obviously have a problem in reading and understanding basic English,

in which my posts were made.

And please do point out where I used the words, "your item is no good"

in any of my posts and further more please do show where I made a low offer for your item!

As you posted outside the Sales Area on a Public Forum, specifically in the:-

Germany: Medals & Militaria > Germany: Post 1945 German Awards, Militaria and History

you invite comments and opinion with regards the item posted,

Any member of the public, before they part with their money has a right to ask questions,

be it at militaria shows, online sales or on a Forum such as this, about any item they wish,

hopefully that's not too hard for you to comprehend.

Kevin in Deva.

[General2]

You obviously have a problem in reading and understanding basic English,

in which my posts were made.

And please do point out where I used the words, "your item is no good"

in any of my posts and further more please do show where I made a low offer for your item!

As you posted outside the Sales Area on a Public Forum, specifically in the:-

Germany: Medals & Militaria > Germany: Post 1945 German Awards, Militaria and History

you invite comments and opinion with regards the item posted,

Any member of the public, before they part with their money has a right to ask questions,

be it at militaria shows, online sales or on a Forum such as this, about any item they wish,

hopefully that's not too hard for you to comprehend.

Kevin in Deva.

Well said Kevin!! IMO the bar is a put together for the reasons you listed above, no soldier would have let such an obvious mistake go unchecked. I would be interested in seeing this guys other items that have incorrect ribbons...pehaps all bought from the same dealer?

Kevin1261, as for your comment: "These are 57 items"....as if to say they do not matter? 1957 medal bars were most likely put together by the same military tailors and their families, who made the WW2 period bars, so they would not make silly mistakes? I used to own quite a few 57er medal bars, and the quality and workmansship etc was just as good as my WW1+WW2 Bars.

John

Edited March 31, 2009 by General2

[kevin1261]

A post war put together??? well ya its a 57 award bar,so it would be post war...I like the 57 bars, i have a few so tight,you cant move the ring around to check for MM's

Well said Kevin!! IMO the bar is a put together for the reasons you listed above, no soldier would have let such an obvious mistake go unchecked. I would be interested in seeing this guys other items that have incorrect ribbons...pehaps all bought from the same dealer?

Kevin1261, as for your comment: "These are 57 items"....as if to say they do not matter? 1957 medal bars were most likely put together by the same military tailors and their families, who made the WW2 period bars, so they would not make silly mistakes? I used to own quite a few 57er medal bars, and the quality and workmansship etc was just as good as my WW1+WW2 Bars.

John

Edited March 31, 2009 by kevin1261

[General2]

A post war put together??? well ya its a 57 award bar,so it would be post war...I like the 57 bars, i have a few so tight,you cant move the ring around to check for MM's

I never said post-war put-together, i just stated it was likely to be a put-together...you seem to have a problem with reading? How about we call it a modern put-together? Does this register with you? Even a modern put-together can be "tight"...i am sure it isn't hard to sew on medals tightly like they did 60 odd years ago.... :rolleyes:

[kevin1261]

###### OFF THis is just bullshit,I came here to try and get 2 pieces together,and I get attacked for not buying it from the original owner,and now for giving a answer to Kev about it being a post war put together.....I dont know...I came to unite to pieces,thats all not to sell to everyone, AS I COULD NOT GET INTO THE SELLING AREA,.....WOW MODS PLEASE PULL MY MEMBERSHIP,and my posts

I never said post-war put-together, i just stated it was likely to be a put-together...you seem to have a problem with reading? How about we call it a modern put-together? Does this register with you? Even a modern put-together can be "tight"...i am sure it isn't hard to sew on medals tightly like they did 60 odd years ago....