taras Posted September 22, 2011 Author Posted September 22, 2011 The stars of "Afrique Francophone" - a common shape. Arthus Bertrand I presume? Republic of Congo-Mali-Senegal and Upper Volta/Burkina Faso-Niger
taras Posted September 22, 2011 Author Posted September 22, 2011 Oops, sorry Republic of Congo-Mali-Senegal
taras Posted November 9, 2011 Author Posted November 9, 2011 Patiala (Indian Princely state) - Malawi 1
taras Posted February 23, 2012 Author Posted February 23, 2012 And once again! Back to the pair #2... (Ethiopia-Montenegro-Colombia) ...and #3 (Armenia-France-Armenia - the new Order of the Glory)
taras Posted March 7, 2012 Author Posted March 7, 2012 Strange similarities: Albania - Moldova Malta - Singapore
peter monahan Posted March 12, 2012 Posted March 12, 2012 (edited) Aside from the obvious ones - all the SSRs with similar Gold Stars - there are two, not mutually exclusive, explanations. Jim has the first one spot on - reusing dies and other bits gives the 'same shirt, new tie' effect. Paart of this too, is almost certainly the deliberately similar designs. How many Latin American countries, for example, who have constitutions based on that of the United States, troops uniformed like those of the US and so on have also designed decorations and medals which recall American orders for similar things. The same true of many former British, French and Spanish colonies, oddly enough, as modern thinking seems to suggest that the former masters are universally loathed and so one might expect the new states to chose designs as far from the old ones as possible. Perhaps military men and civil servants everywhere are closer to each other than to their civilian compatriots? The other explanation is whatever one calls the artistic equivalent of plagarism! There are a finite number of variations on circles and stars after all, and artists with a contract to fill will start with some research into what's out there already and, probably without deliberate copying come up with designs that draw on what they have seen. At least part of the explanation for some of the truly ghastly medal ribbons out there these days, IMHO, is the difficulty in finding any combination of sane colours that someone isn't already using! The same must be true of the medals themselves: given the finite number of symbols - eagles, swords, crowns... - with which to adress martial themes one has a virtual recipe for design derivatives! I believe that most musical plagarism suits come down to the similarities in a bar or two which, given eight notes to work with, surprisingly rarely, again in my view, as I'm surprised how many distinctive tunes can be made with thise few variables. And, of course, there are lazy artists just as there are lazy writers and some work is apparently too good not to copy. Great thread! Peter Edited March 12, 2012 by peter monahan
JapanX Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 Two additional classic examples for Taras collection. Egyptian Order of the Republic vs. Yemeni Order of Mareb (Marib).
JapanX Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 Both orders were made by the very same workshop of Bichay in Cairo in 50s-60s (even hallmarks on reverses are identical). Time for two Asian beauties Japanese Order of Rising Sun vs. Korean Order of Tuiguk (a.k.a. Taeguk)
JapanX Posted April 26, 2012 Posted April 26, 2012 And another example. Belgian Civil Decoration for Long Service vs. Civil Merit Order of Congo Connection between these two is obvious as well as reasons for copycat practice
JapanX Posted May 11, 2012 Posted May 11, 2012 US Purple Hear vs. Taiwan Medal of Loyalty and Integrity Obverses
taras Posted May 11, 2012 Author Posted May 11, 2012 And - look at much more surprising similarity: Haitian Empire (mid 19-th century) - Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan (1970s)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now