EK 1939 IC 1939 1st class mm 107

[genoa41]

I have moved this thread here to be thrashed out. Once a conclusion has been reached it will be moved back to the relevant sales area.

Hello

For sale a nice IC 1st class mm 107

Asking 180 euro + shipping ; paypal (fees 4%) or bank transfer

Thanks

[genoa41]

Hello

For sale a nice IC 1st class mm 107

Asking 180 euro + shipping ; paypal (fees 4%) or bank transfer

Thanks

[Motorhead]

Hmmm-I hate to be the bringer of bad news-this one is never a 107 Carl Wild! It looks like the common fake with the varios maker marks!

Micha

[Guest Darrell]

I agree with Micha ... just saw this thread.

Those rounded corners give this one away ...

Edited April 25, 2006 by Darrell

[ekhunter]

I agree with Micha ... just saw this thread.

Those rounded corners give this one away ...

I'm new here, but I can gaurantee you that this is not a 107 "made" cross.

[genoa41]

I'm new here, but I can gaurantee you that this is not a 107 "made" cross.

Dear Sir

It is certainly rewarding to deal with qualified people , but this time I must disagree with you .

My opinion is that a well-known german dealer is not going to stake his good name for a few euros .

Therefore , while I appreciate your remark that I consider technically noteworthy, I go on giving credit to my dealer

yours sincerely

[ekhunter]

Dear Sir

It is certainly rewarding to deal with qualified people , but this time I must disagree with you .

My opinion is that a well-known german dealer is not going to stake his good name for a few euros .

Therefore , while I appreciate your remark that I consider technically noteworthy, I go on giving credit to my dealer

yours sincerely

Respectfully taken, and it is O.K. to agree to disagree. However, please don't believe that "some" well known dealers won't stake their good name for a few Euro's. I know, because I myself got burned by a Floch several years ago by a well known dealer. It happens! I only said that because the pin, catch, and the "rounder" edges don't match any known example of a 107 marked cross. Tonight I will try to post a picture of a Carl Wild 1st class pinback that is generally accepted by 99.999 of collector's and dealers as the "real" deal. Good luck in your endeavors, and once again, I did not mean to offend.

Edited April 28, 2006 by ekhunter

[dond]

Perhaps it needs moved to the discussion area to give buyers a warm and fuzzy.

Don

[Nick]

I agree this needs to be thrashed out in the EK Section. So I have moved it there.

[Dave B]

I agree with the others I'm afraid,the cross is not looking good at all ...have a look at this link for some original examples of a 107 EK1 http://gmic.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=7719

Dave

[ekhunter]

This is a Carl Wild 107 pinback. This is a "text book" example for comparison purposes.

[attachmentid=36883][attachmentid=36882][attachmentid=36881]

[Jan Arne S]

Hi !

I also agree with the others here !

The first showed EK 1 mm "107" in this thread is a well known fake , and can be found with a lot of different markers marks .

Jan Arne

[David Robertson]

HI all

Dave B posted the link that says it all,great photos of good 107 made EKI's . The only thing I can do is repeat what has already been posted, The one posted for sale is a common fake and seen with all kinds of makers on them.

David R.

[genoa41]

I agree this needs to be thrashed out in the EK Section. So I have moved it there.

Dear Sir

I apologize for being late in answering your remarks but I am just back from my holidays.

I am really grateful for yours accurate analysis and sharp comments .

I will certainly make the most of your expertise as to other badges

yours sincerely

[DavidM]

Hello

The cross in question, as has already been pointed out, is a fake. What I'd be interested to know is who the dealer is that is peddling this rubbish.

[Minas Henrik]

Hi!

Lovely Crosses in this thred indeed and nice lookking to i realy love them all.

Best Regards Henrik.