I know right off the bat that this will have some who think it good, and some who think it bad. Here is my thinking Negatives - Private piece - No period thing to compare it to - Does not have to be WW1 - Darker color - We will never know for sure Positives - Material is good - Obviously old and worn - Collar and fittings very "Military" - Piping looks very kosher Neutrals - Traces that other buttons were originally on this, 2cm to the left of where they are now. I personally like this a lot, but I did not find it in a barn or get it from the family, so I cannot say "its a sure thing!" ... What do you guys think?