I think its absurd to discuss this badge. The bavarian badges are a mine field. I think no one can definitely say what is genuine what private purchase and what is a post war production and wich one is modern make. If someone like his badge and think is genuine, so what. There are a lot of assertions but no facts. For me i don't buy any bavarian aviation badges more, only they come directly from the family and it looks good in me eyes. @VINLAND30 If you and your friend like this badge it's OK. Not all people share the same opinon but if you feel confident its your problem. Regards Alex