I vote keep them together. Odd things show up with research. If the Canadian Forestry chap was a poseur (and they've always been about since the days of the Roman legions I suspect), then it makes a better story in and of itself. However, sometimes odd things happen. I was an unpaid lackey at a local Senators' office and did mostly medal requests and veterans' affairs stuff whilst I was in Law school. Once I had a request come in for a Soldier's Medal that was supposed to have been awarded to a retired colonel who personally dragged a crewman out of burning bomber on Tinian in late 1945. After almost a years' worth of research requests and counter requests with the archives and some of the least intelligent people I've met in the Pentagon, i got the days' action reports along with a series of other unrelated documents that showed everything happened as the officer said it had, but all the men under his command (whom he had personally led) got the Soldier's medal. The officer had filled out the paperwork for his men, but his CO never did . I did not let this go. 9 (!) years later, after the man had died, we finally were able locate the duty rosters and the units' summary, which had the magical line: "Major Pray led the rescue team personally and was singed by the exploding gasoline tanks as he pulled Sgt. Walters" from the plane." Thus, a mere 62 years after the original incident, his widow got the medal. The original research requests came back with the statement" "There is no record of Major Pray having been in the Asia-Pacific theater". You never know.