Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Recommended Posts

    Posted (edited)

    I don't know how the bar appears in hand but with those crappy pictures only a period photograph of this bar in wear could convince me.

    Edited by Naxos
    Posted

    Hi Rick ,

    The fifth ribbon is is for the Carl Eduard medal 2nd class without swords, isn't it ? It may be the clue to id this ribbon bar.

    Christophe

    Posted

    I know it's good. The Other Rick knows it's good too. What I want...... is for you'se guys to tell me why!

    :whistle:

    Why is it good? I think my question is why did the gent put it together with such an odd precedence order?

    Posted

    Hi Rick ,

    The fifth ribbon is is for the Carl Eduard medal 2nd class without swords, isn't it ? It may be the clue to id this ribbon bar.

    Christophe

    Christophe,

    I think that is a Württemberg ribbon.;)

    Best wishes

    Matt

    Posted

    I know it's good. The Other Rick knows it's good too. What I want...... is for you'se guys to tell me why!

    :whistle:

    Rick,

    Has the answer got anything to do with the reverse?

    Best wishes

    Matt

    Posted

    I think that this bar has been made after 1918. Probably EK2 as first ribbon and on 4th, HHO3X or KO4X (like there is a China ribbon).

    Posted

    AWESOME! The bar will be there with a scan of both sides and a detailed report from the chief research gnome. Big box of bars enroute to my house btw.... should be interesting!

    Posted

    I don't have to convince anyone, but liked the bar even back when you (and or other Rick?) claimed it not to be good...

    :P

    Sure it's a ribbon bar? It justed to come with awards on it...

    Posted

    OK, falling back from my previous post. Upon close examination (and serious fondling by Geoff.....) this was made as a medal bar.

    There is evidence of threads that would have tied down ose's, slight curling of ribbon edges where medals were sewn in and lumps of thread from the same below the ribbons.

    Unfortunately, being completely befuddled by an ASTONISHINGLY fabuluous German meal of spaetzle, red cabbage and wursts..... supplied by WildCard (much thanks, much thanks, much thanks) and besotted with home-made Ginger Snaps from Mother Research..... I waltzed out without my scans. So, I will make new ones when I have recuperated fully from the conclave.

    Posted

    I just read it..... I see I never posted in that thread. perhaps I didn't agree with RR at the time, I don't know. But having said that, I will be calling him shortly to tell him what was on the bar in 2009!

    Good eye Sasha, I had no recollection of the bar from before. Since Ulan was in China, I wonder if he stripped the bar and resold it based on what was said here......

    Posted

    OK, the only comment he had was "I should have been a weatherman".

    The crux of the bar back then would still be the MVO4X on a statute ribbon. Someone had to have swapped out the pre-1915 MVK (blue enamel, no flames) for the more common MVO4x. That's the one piece that makes no sense to me from the prior thread.

    Thoughts?

    Posted

    It could be any scenario and I still believe a WW1 MVO 4th class could be possible if the guy got bumped up from EM/NCO to junior officer.

    The pre-1913 MVKs were the none or few enemaled ones, awarded e. g. for africa. For China, you're right with the blue ones - that's the pre-1905 one classed type. See one I used to have here.

    Württemberg medal should be a WW1 award as the early (pre-WW1) ones were worn on a dark blue ribbon... unless they switched it. But why switch a Württemberg ribbon and wear the Bavarian order on non-matching ribbon... Rick sais they were not awarded to senior NCOs... so there still is something fishy. Same with Austrian bravery medal...

    Ulan returned the bar, from what I understood. Probably the former seller then butchered it. or anyone else. Who knows.

    Maybe the bar is real, but had been butchered before and was re-filled wrongly?

    Did Rick come up with something more than it's a good one? A possible wearer - with other awards?

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now
    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.