Jump to content
News Ticker
  • I am now accepting the following payment methods: Card Payments, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal
  • Latest News

    Recommended Posts

    Posted

    I've studied the larger scans and if I had to make a call on these two medals I would say that they are both repros/fakes.

    Sergei is right in saying that basing oneself on scans is not the most reliable way of authenticating a medal or order. However, there are usually little tell tale marks which give can help to reaching conclusions and based on what I can see I would not go for these medals myself.

    Sorry if this is not what you may want to hear from us guys but its always better this way. :(

    May I ask what you paid for these medals as they are not exactly the cheapest ones around......

    Jim

    • Replies 96
    • Created
    • Last Reply

    Top Posters In This Topic

    Posted

    Jim,

    Are you referring to my larger scans or OoV's scans? If it's mine, do you reckon both of my pictures are fakes? Between the two of us we posted too many scans!

    Thanks,

    Sergei

    Posted

    I've studied the larger scans and if I had to make a call on these two medals I would say that they are both repros/fakes.

    Sergei is right in saying that basing oneself on scans is not the most reliable way of authenticating a medal or order. However, there are usually little tell tale marks which give can help to reaching conclusions and based on what I can see I would not go for these medals myself.

    Sorry if this is not what you may want to hear from us guys but its always better this way. :(

    May I ask what you paid for these medals as they are not exactly the cheapest ones around......

    Jim

    Hi Jim,

    I bought a a collection of Medals that were purchased in Georgia a while back mainly for the Screw back Red Banner and got these a Boarder guards medal and fire fighters one and a load of other bits throw in so Idont have a general price :unsure:

    Its just good to no what you have weather it be genuine or fake ;)

    Order of Victory

    Guest Darrell
    Posted

    They are NOT cheap. The documented pair I showed to start the thread off cost me:

    1st Class Documented = 350 US$

    2nd Class Documented = 325 US$

    That was about 1 year ago.

    Posted

    Precisely Darell! My point is that I was just hoping OOV did not pay a fortune for them!!

    Georgia & Latvia amongst other states seem to be churning out some good fakes at 'tempting prices'. The buyer thinking he's on a winner .... well frankly gets shafted! :(

    Jim

    Posted (edited)

    BTW does any one have any suggesions why these are full scratches :unsure:

    Order of Victory

    My guess is they are casting flaws, and since the original medal was struck and not cast that would make them copies.

    But I'm not an expert.

    I should post my PM1 here. Hang on....

    Edited by Eric Gaumann
    Posted

    And closer-up of the medallions:

    I believe (as told both other, more knowledgeable folks) that this is a fairly good copy (aka Fake).

    The less than crisp details on the faces (moustaches, collars, tie knot) are bad points although there are other details that I do think are good.

    I'd love to hear other opinions though so please gimme your best shot. :)

    Guest Darrell
    Posted

    Hello :cheers:

    I believe these are fakes as well.

    Posted

    Hi Eric.

    i agree with Darrel, thats not an original. Maybe i should add, the copies of the Partisan Medal are damned good sometimes..

    Gerd

    Without a shadow of doubt! Cast copies and at first glance, the quality of the relief and suspension rings are very clear evidence that these are not original.

    Jim :cheers:

    • 8 months later...
    Posted

    Nice salty medal as I like them! Ed do you have any other partisan medals in your collection or you are expecting to find one in a group one day?

    Posted

    Nice salty medal as I like them! Ed do you have any other partisan medals in your collection or you are expecting to find one in a group one day?

    This is the only ONLY one. Came "rogued" into a "group" (as referenced above), but my peculiar joy lies in groups (with HISTORY), and partisan groups are almost too good ever to hope for (these dark days of Soviet collecting).

    But is it "kosher"??? About these medals, I have much fear.

    Posted (edited)

    While Igor's prices always tend toward the high end of the curve, these are the sorts of prices one encounters, yes. For that reason, it has become widely faked. Hence, my questions about my second class.

    Edited by Ed_Haynes
    Guest Darrell
    Posted

    While Igor's prices always tend toward the high end of the curve, ........

    Ed, I think that's the understatement of the year. I got the documented one for ~ $350 within 18 months ago. Price gouging and a monopoly on the market is what I call those ridiculous prices :speechless1:

    • 1 month later...

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



    ×
    ×
    • Create New...

    Important Information

    We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.